At The Brancato Law Firm in Tampa, we defend people facing constructive possession charges. Our founder, Rocky Brancato, has spent more than 25 years in Hillsborough County’s criminal justice system. He served as Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, the largest criminal defense operation in Tampa Bay, so he knows how the local system handles drug cases from the defense side.

What Does the State Have to Prove in a Constructive Possession Case?

All three of the following have to be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. If even one of them is not proven, you cannot be convicted of possession.

• You knew the drugs were there. Knowing means you were aware the drugs were in the car, room or bag.
• You could control the drugs. Control means you had the power to decide what happened to the drugs, such as keeping them, moving them or getting rid of them. The State tries to prove control by showing that you control the place where the drugs were found, such as a car you drive or a bedroom that is yours. It can also try to show that you hid the drugs there.
• The substance is the drug named in the charge. If the charge says cocaine, the State has to prove the substance was cocaine.

The State does not have to prove the drugs belonged to you. Florida defines possession by knowledge and control, so drugs owned by a friend or roommate can still be charged as yours if you knew about them and could control them. That is why saying “they weren’t mine” does not end the case by itself.

Whether anyone else used the place changes how the State proves knowledge. If you were the only person using the car or room, Florida’s jury instruction allows the jury to infer that you knew the drugs were there. If other people shared it, the jury is not allowed to make that inference, and the State has to prove your knowledge with other evidence. That evidence can be circumstantial evidence, meaning facts that point to your knowledge without directly proving it.

What Is the Difference Between Actual and Constructive Possession?

In actual possession, the drugs are on your body, so where they were found shows you possessed them. Drugs close enough for you to reach easily also count as actual possession, but only if they are under your control. The State still has to prove you knew about them. In constructive possession, the drugs are somewhere else, so the State has to prove both your knowledge and your control from the circumstances.

Constructive possession is not limited to drugs. Florida uses the same idea for other things that are illegal to possess, such as a firearm when the person charged is a convicted felon, or child sexual abuse material (CSAM) found on a shared computer. In each of these cases, the State has to show that you knew the item was there and could control it, and sharing the car, home or computer with other people makes that harder to prove.

Is Being Near Drugs Enough for a Possession Charge?

No, when the drugs are in a place someone else controls, being close to them does not prove you possessed them. Florida’s jury instruction tells jurors that closeness alone does not show control in that situation. For example, if you were visiting a friend’s apartment and police found drugs in your friend’s kitchen cabinet, being in the apartment would not prove you possessed those drugs. The State would need evidence that ties you to them.

What If the Drugs Were Found in a Shared Car or Home?

A place counts as shared when more than one person uses it. That includes the rooms everyone uses in a home you rent with a roommate, such as the kitchen and living room. It also includes your own car when other people are riding in it. Sharing a place does not clear you. Florida’s jury instruction says two or more people can possess the same drugs at the same time. This is called joint possession, and each of those people is considered to be in possession.

Sharing does change the evidence the State needs. In Brown v. State, the Florida Supreme Court held in 1983 that when a place is shared, both your knowledge of the drugs and your ability to control them “must be established by independent proof.” Independent proof means evidence other than your connection to the place, such as something you said or your fingerprints.

Brown also made one exception to the independent proof rule, for drugs in plain view. Plain view means the drugs were out in the open where anyone could see them. When drugs are in plain view in a shared place, and an owner or occupant of that place is present, the court held that those facts are enough to support that person’s conviction for constructive possession. An occupant is someone who lives in the place or shares control of it, such as a roommate who rents the apartment but does not own it.

A passenger riding in someone else’s car and a guest visiting someone else’s home do not count as occupants under this rule. For them, drugs in plain view are not automatically enough for a conviction, and the State needs other evidence that ties them to the drugs. Two decisions from Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal show what happens when the State has no other evidence against a visitor or a passenger. That court hears appeals from Hillsborough, Pinellas and Pasco counties, so its decisions apply to cases there.

• In Sundin v. State, the court reversed the conviction of a man visiting a hotel room he had not rented, even though the drugs were within his reach.
• In Wynn v. State, the court reversed a passenger’s conviction for cocaine found in the driver’s-side door handle. The cocaine was not in plain view, and the State had no evidence connecting the passenger to it.

Can You Give Me an Example of Constructive Possession?

These four hypothetical situations show which facts tend to help the State and which tend to help the defense:

• Your own car, driving alone. Police find pills in the glove box of a car you own and no one else drives. Because you alone control the car, the jury may infer you knew about the pills. These facts favor the State.
• Your own car, with a friend riding along. Police find the same pills in the closed glove box while your friend sits in the passenger seat. The car is shared, so the jury cannot infer that you knew about the pills. Unless the State has other evidence tying you to them, these facts favor the defense.
• A friend’s car, with drugs in plain sight. You are a passenger, and a bag of powder is sitting on the center console. As a passenger, you are not an occupant under the plain view rule, so the bag being visible is not automatically enough for a conviction. Without other evidence tying you to the bag, these facts favor the defense.
• A shared apartment, with drugs on the coffee table. You rent an apartment with a roommate, and police find cocaine on the living room coffee table while you are home. You are an occupant, and the drugs were in plain view. These facts favor the State.

What Evidence Do Prosecutors Use to Prove Constructive Possession?

Florida courts have accepted these kinds of evidence as proof that ties a specific person to drugs found in a shared space:

• Your own statements. Telling police the drugs are yours, that you bought them, or that you use drugs can connect you to the drugs.
• Items found with the drugs that match what you told police. In Thompson v. State, a man told police he had bought methamphetamine and described how he used drugs. A straw found with the drugs fit that description, and the court held that his statements and the straw together were enough to tie him to the drugs.
• Fingerprints or DNA. Physical evidence can tie you to the drugs themselves.

Is Constructive Possession Punished Less Than Actual Possession?

For drug charges, the penalties are the same, because Florida’s drug law treats actual and constructive possession as one offense. The penalty depends on the drug and the amount. Possessing a controlled substance is generally a third-degree felony, which carries up to five years in prison. Possessing 20 grams or less of marijuana is a first-degree misdemeanor, which carries a sentence of up to one year. Larger amounts of a drug can lead to a separate charge of drug trafficking. Our Tampa drug crimes defense page explains how the penalties change for other drugs and amounts.

That is not true of every possession charge. A convicted felon can be found guilty of possessing a firearm under section 790.23 of the Florida Statutes through either actual or constructive possession. But the three-year minimum mandatory prison sentence in section 775.087(2)(a)1 applies only when the felon actually possessed the firearm. If the State can prove only constructive possession, such as a gun found in a bedroom closet, that minimum mandatory does not apply.

How Do You Fight a Constructive Possession Charge?

These are the main defenses:

• You did not know the drugs were there. If someone else left the drugs in a car or room you use and you never knew about them, the State cannot prove you knew.
• The drugs were in a place someone else controlled. Drugs in another person’s bedroom, purse or backpack are in a place that person controls, and being near them does not prove you controlled them.
• Nothing ties you to drugs in a shared space. Without evidence such as your statements or your fingerprints, sharing the car or home where the drugs were found is not enough to prove you possessed them.
• You did not know the substance was an illegal drug. This defense applies when you knew the substance was there but did not know it was an illegal drug.
• The search was illegal. If police searched the car, home or bag without a legal basis, a motion to suppress can keep the State from using the drugs as evidence against you. If the drugs are kept out, the State may not have enough evidence left to continue the case.
• The evidence is too weak to go to trial. When the State’s evidence cannot show knowledge or control, a motion to dismiss asks the court to end the case before trial.

The defense of not knowing a substance was illegal comes from section 893.101 of the Florida Statutes. For example, it would apply if you knew a pill bottle was in your car but believed it held a legal medication. The State does not have to prove you knew a substance was illegal. Instead, your lack of knowledge is an affirmative defense, meaning a defense you raise yourself. It gives the jury a reason not to convict you even if the State proves the things it has to prove.

If you raise this defense, the jury is told that the law allows jurors to presume that a person who possessed a controlled substance knew the substance was illegal. The jury does not have to accept that presumption. If it believes you did not know the substance was illegal, it can find you not guilty. The defense does not help if your position is that you never knew the drugs were there, because that is a different question the State has to prove.

When a case involves a search, it helps to know how police are trained to conduct one. Our founder, Rocky Brancato, taught criminal procedure to officers as a police academy instructor. Our team uses that knowledge to compare what the officers in your case did with what they were taught to do. When the officers did not follow their training, we use that to challenge their testimony about the search.

In Florida, prosecutors decide after an arrest whether to file formal charges. The defense can present its arguments to prosecutors before they make that decision. When drugs are found in a shared car or shared luggage, we challenge whether the State can prove constructive possession. Luggage on a trip is a common example. When several people packed, carried or had access to the same suitcase, the State has to show which of them knew about the drugs and could control them. If the evidence cannot answer that, it is an argument we can raise with prosecutors before charges are filed.

Knowledge matters even when the drugs are found on your body. In a trial we describe in our case study It’s the Client’s Call, a client was charged after hospital staff found cocaine in his pants pocket while he was being treated for a medical emergency. No witness ever saw him conscious and in control of the drugs, and the jury found him not guilty. Each case is unique. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Frequently Asked Questions About Constructive Possession in Florida

Should I talk to police about drugs found near me?

Talk to a criminal defense attorney before you say anything more to police about the drugs. In a shared car or home, your own words can be the evidence that ties you to drugs the State otherwise could not connect to you. Even saying “those belong to my roommate” can help the State, because it shows you knew the drugs were there.

Can I be convicted for drugs found in my roommate’s bedroom?

If you do not use your roommate’s bedroom, it is a place your roommate controls. Living in the same apartment does not prove you possessed drugs kept there. The State would need evidence tying you to those specific drugs, such as your fingerprints or something you said about them.

Does the State need fingerprints or DNA to prove constructive possession?

No, Florida does not require fingerprints or DNA to prove constructive possession. Other evidence, such as your own statements, can connect you to the drugs instead. The State still needs some evidence beyond the fact that you were near the drugs. In one Florida appeals case, two people could reach the drugs equally, and the State offered no fingerprints, DNA or other evidence tying the accused to them. The court reversed the conviction.

Talk to Us About a Constructive Possession Charge

A possession charge for drugs that were not on you is frightening, especially before you know what evidence the State has. If you or someone close to you has been charged with possession for drugs found in a car, home or bag, we can review the evidence the State has connecting you to those drugs and explain what it means for your case. Call The Brancato Law Firm at (813) 727-7159 for a free, confidential consultation. We are available 24/7 when someone has just been arrested. Our office is at 620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, in downtown Tampa.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

No. Under Florida Statute 790.23, a convicted felon cannot own, possess, or have in their care, custody, or control any firearm, ammunition, or electric weapon or device. Violating that law is a second-degree felony carrying up to 15 years in prison, and actual possession of the firearm triggers a 3-year mandatory minimum sentence. The ban stays in place unless firearm authority has been restored through executive clemency. A narrow exception also applies to juvenile records that have been expunged under Florida Statute 943.0515(1)(b).

The Brancato Law Firm practices criminal defense exclusively. We defend clients charged with felon in possession of a firearm across Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties. We do not handle clemency petitions or firearm rights restoration. That process is mainly political and only a little bit legal, and the section below explains what we mean by that.

One development is worth watching in 2026: Florida’s Attorney General has told a state appellate court that the categorical ban on nondangerous felons possessing firearms is unconstitutional, in Morgan v. State, No. 1D2025-0377, now pending in the First District Court of Appeal. That case is still pending. Section 790.23 is still being enforced against people arrested today.

What Florida Statute 790.23 Prohibits

Florida’s felon-in-possession law is broad. It is unlawful for any person to own or have in their care, custody, possession, or control any firearm, ammunition, or electric weapon or device, or to carry a concealed weapon, including a tear gas gun or chemical weapon or device, if that person has been:

• Convicted of a felony in any Florida court
• Found to have committed a delinquent act in Florida that would be a felony if committed by an adult (if the person is under 24)
• Convicted of or found to have committed a federal felony (no minimum sentence length required)
• Found guilty of an offense that is a felony in another state, territory, or country and was punishable by more than one year in prison
• Found to have committed a delinquent act in another state, territory, or country that would be a felony punishable by more than one year if committed by an adult (if the person is under 24)

The word “firearm” is defined broadly under Florida Statute 790.001(9) to include any weapon designed to expel a projectile by the action of an explosive, along with frames, receivers, silencers, destructive devices, and machine guns. That same definition contains the exception we discuss below: the term “firearm” does not include an antique firearm unless the antique firearm is used in the commission of a crime.

The statute covers ammunition and electric weapons separately. A convicted felon who possesses a single round of ammunition is violating the same law as one who possesses a loaded handgun.

Florida’s broader gun laws also restrict where and how firearms can be carried, even for people who are legally allowed to possess them. Our overview of gun crime laws in Florida covers those restrictions, and we have written separately about carrying at a Buccaneers game.

Penalties for Felon in Possession of a Firearm in Florida

A standard felon-in-possession conviction is a second-degree felony. Depending on the circumstances, the penalties escalate significantly.

Under Florida’s 10-20-Life law, Fla. Stat. § 775.087, anyone who actually possessed a firearm during the commission of the offense faces a 3-year mandatory minimum. A prior conviction for one of the felonies listed in Fla. Stat. § 775.084(1)(b)1 pushes that mandatory minimum to 10 years, but only if the defendant actually possessed a firearm or destructive device during that earlier felony as well. If the charge involves gang activity under Section 874.04, Section 790.23(4) makes the offense a first-degree felony punishable by a term of years not exceeding life. And if the defendant meets the violent career criminal criteria, the charge is not Section 790.23 at all. It is Section 790.235, a first-degree felony carrying a 15-year mandatory minimum with no discretionary early release.

Which type of possession the state can prove controls whether a mandatory minimum applies to your case at all.

Actual Possession vs. Constructive Possession

This distinction carries real sentencing consequences, and it is one of the most contested issues in felon-in-possession cases.

The sentencing difference is the reason prosecutors and defense attorneys fight over this. Only actual possession triggers the 3-year mandatory minimum under Section 775.087, and Section 775.087(4) defines actual possession to require that the firearm was within immediate physical reach with ready access and that the defendant intended to use it during the commission of the offense. That intent element is frequently the defense’s strongest argument in reach cases. When the state can prove only constructive possession, the judge keeps discretion over the sentence.

Proximity alone does not establish constructive possession. If you were a passenger in someone else’s vehicle, or if other people had equal access to the place the gun was found, the state has to prove more than your presence near it. Florida’s standard jury instructions require proof that the defendant knew of the firearm and had the ability to control it.

In our experience defending these cases in Hillsborough County, the actual versus constructive question is frequently the central issue at trial. How the firearm was discovered, where it was located, who else had access, and what the defendant said or did not say to officers all feed into that analysis.

Federal Law Bans Felons From Having Guns Too

Even if Florida changes its state law, federal law independently prohibits convicted felons from possessing firearms. Under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1), any person convicted of a crime punishable by more than one year of imprisonment is prohibited from possessing any firearm or ammunition that has been shipped or transported in interstate commerce.

A federal felon-in-possession conviction carries up to 15 years in federal prison. Under the Armed Career Criminal Act, 18 U.S.C. § 924(e), three or more prior convictions for violent felonies or serious drug offenses raise the mandatory minimum to 15 years.

Two points about federal law matter here:

• How complete your state restoration is determines whether the federal ban survives it. Florida can restore your state-level right to possess firearms through executive clemency. Under 18 U.S.C. § 921(a)(20), a conviction for which civil rights have been restored is not a conviction for federal purposes unless the restoration expressly provides that the person may not possess firearms. Florida’s plain Restoration of Civil Rights does expressly withhold firearm authority, so the federal ban survives it. A full restoration, meaning civil rights together with Specific Authority to Own, Possess, or Use Firearms, removes the federal disability arising from that Florida conviction. None of this helps with a federal or out-of-state conviction, which only the jurisdiction that entered it can relieve.
  
• The DOJ reopened federal relief in August 2026. On August 17, 2026, the Justice Department finalized its rule implementing 18 U.S.C. § 925(c) and launched the Federal Firearm Rights Restoration program, administered by the Office of the Pardon Attorney rather than ATF. Applications open to invited candidates on September 25, 2026 and to the public on November 4, 2026, capped at the first 5,000 filings, with a further 500 slots and a $30 application fee opening in early 2027. Relief is individualized and never guaranteed. The rule builds in presumptions against relief: a permanent presumptive bar for violent felonies, ten years for drug trafficking and certain firearms offenses, and five years for most other felonies, measured from completion of every component of the sentence, including restitution. Apart from a presidential pardon, this is the only route for a federal conviction.
  

Anyone whose state firearm rights have been restored should understand that picking up a firearm can still result in federal prosecution.

Exceptions to Florida’s Felon Gun Ban

Florida’s felon-in-possession law has several exceptions. Some are statutory. Others depend on how the underlying conviction was handled.

• Executive clemency with firearm authority: A grant of Specific Authority to Own, Possess, or Use Firearms (Rules 4.I.F and 5.D of the Rules of Executive Clemency), which is a separate form of clemency from Restoration of Civil Rights, from the Florida Executive Clemency Board lifts the state ban.
  
• Expunged juvenile record: If your juvenile criminal history record has been expunged under Florida Statute 943.0515(1)(b), Section 790.23(2)(b) exempts you by name. This is a narrow, juvenile-only exception. An adult felony conviction cannot be sealed or expunged in Florida at all. Both Section 943.0585 and Section 943.059 require that adjudication was withheld, which by definition means there was never a conviction.
  
• Withheld adjudication (adults): A felony charge that resulted in a withhold of adjudication was never a formal conviction under Florida law. Section 790.23 applies to people who have been convicted, so a withheld adjudication for an adult does not trigger the ban. The Florida Supreme Court settled this in Clarke v. United States, 184 So. 3d 1107 (Fla. 2016), where a man charged federally after a Florida guilty plea with adjudication withheld asked whether that plea counted as a conviction. The court held it did not, and the Eleventh Circuit then vacated his federal conviction. Two limits matter. The exception applies to Florida convictions under subsection (1)(a). Subsections (1)(c) and (1)(e) reach a person “found to have committed” a federal felony or “found guilty” of an out-of-state felony, which is broader language a withhold-style disposition may not escape. And a juvenile finding counts even where adjudication of delinquency was withheld.
  
• An important limit on the withhold exception: Falling outside Section 790.23 does not make you an ordinary buyer. FDLE must deny a dealer purchase for anyone who has had adjudication withheld on any felony unless three years have elapsed since probation or any other court-ordered conditions were fulfilled (Section 790.065(2)(a)3), and the same three-year rule disqualifies you from a concealed weapon license (Section 790.06(2)(k)). While you are still on probation, firearm possession is almost always a condition of supervision regardless of the withhold.
  
• Antique firearms: Florida law excludes antique firearms from the definition of “firearm.” An antique firearm is one manufactured in or before 1918, or a replica of one, whether the replica itself was made before or after 1918, or a firearm using fixed ammunition manufactured in or before 1918 that is no longer manufactured in the United States and not readily available commercially. A genuine antique falls outside the ban unless it is used in the commission of a crime. Two practical notes: antique status is an affirmative defense you have to raise rather than something the State must disprove up front, Williams v. State, 468 So. 2d 447 (Fla. 1st DCA 1985), and the carve-out lives in the definition of “firearm” only, so the separate bans on ammunition and electric weapons still apply.
  

Each exception comes with conditions. If you believe an exception covers your situation, talk to an attorney before you act on that belief. The cost of being wrong is a second-degree felony charge.

How to Restore Firearm Rights in Florida

Before the mechanics, the thing nobody tells you: this is a political process, not a legal one. The Clemency Board is the Governor and the three members of the Cabinet, and clemency is an executive act. There is no legal standard to satisfy, no burden of proof, no right to relief, and no appeal from a denial. Rule 4 of the Rules of Executive Clemency states that the Governor “has the unfettered discretion to deny clemency at any time, for any reason.” A lawyer can make sure an application is complete, accurate and eligible. Nothing a lawyer files controls the outcome.

That is also the reason our firm does not take these matters, and we would rather say it plainly than leave it unexplained. The legal part, meaning confirming eligibility, assembling a complete and accurate application, and making sure the financial conditions are satisfied, is real, but it is the small part. The rest is executive discretion, and no filing controls it. We are not willing to charge a criminal defense fee for work whose outcome we cannot influence. If that balance changes, whether because the Legislature creates a judicial path to restoration or because the courts adopt the as-applied argument the Attorney General is now making in Morgan and firearm rights become something a lawyer can litigate rather than petition for, we will look at it again. Until then, if you are seeking clemency, firearm authority, or federal relief under Section 925(c), the Office of Executive Clemency at (850) 488-2952 is where the process begins, and attorneys who handle clemency full time are better positioned than we are. We set the process out here because people charged under Section 790.23 ask about it constantly and the accurate answer is hard to find.

The formal path runs through the executive clemency process, with investigations conducted by the Florida Commission on Offender Review.

The current requirements for firearm authority specifically:

• You must wait at least 8 years after completing all terms of your sentence, including prison, probation, parole, fines, restitution, and any other court-ordered conditions

• The 8 years runs from the date all sentences and all conditions of supervision on your most recent felony expired or were completed. Time served is what starts the clock, not what runs it
• A new felony conviction after the waiting period begins resets the clock, because the clock always runs from your most recent felony
• Persons convicted in a federal, military, or out-of-state court are not eligible to apply for Florida firearm authority at all
• You must have no outstanding detainers, no pecuniary penalties or liabilities totaling more than $1,000 from any criminal conviction or traffic infraction, and no outstanding victim restitution or Chapter 960 obligations
• The application goes to the Clemency Board, which evaluates the petition and schedules a hearing
• Approval requires the Governor plus at least two Cabinet members, and the Governor’s vote is always required. The rules give the Governor unfettered discretion to deny clemency at any time, for any reason

Florida offers two different forms of restoration, and people frequently confuse them:

Firearm authority is the hardest form of clemency Florida grants. There is no administrative track for it. Rules 9 and 10 cover Restoration of Civil Rights only and both expressly exclude firearms, so every firearm application is investigated by the Florida Commission on Offender Review, including a personal interview, and then heard by the Clemency Board, which meets four times a year. Attorneys who file these routinely describe waits of three to twelve years from application to decision. Eight years of eligibility is where the process begins, not where it ends.

One point that causes regular confusion: Amendment 4 to the Florida Constitution, passed in 2018, restored voting rights for most people with felony convictions upon completion of all terms of their sentence, excluding those convicted of murder or a felony sexual offense. Restoration is not automatic in practice. Florida Statute 98.0751 defines “completion of all terms of sentence” to include full payment of restitution and of every fine and fee ordered as part of the sentence, and the Eleventh Circuit upheld that requirement sitting en banc in Jones v. Governor of Florida, 975 F.3d 1016 (11th Cir. 2020). Outstanding court debt keeps a person off the voter rolls. Amendment 4 also restores voting only. Jury service and the right to hold office still require clemency. Amendment 4 did not restore firearm rights. Voting and firearm rights follow separate paths in Florida.

Is Florida’s Felon Gun Ban Changing? Morgan v. State

The most significant development in this area is currently before Florida’s First District Court of Appeal, in Morgan v. State, No. 1D2025-0377.

In September 2022, Christopher Morgan, who had a single nonviolent 2007 Pennsylvania felony conviction for carrying a firearm without a license, was stopped by a Tallahassee police officer during a routine traffic stop. Morgan volunteered that he had an unloaded pistol in his center console and disclosed his prior felony conviction. He was arrested and charged under Section 790.23.

Morgan pleaded no contest but reserved his right to appeal, arguing that Florida’s categorical ban on felons possessing firearms violates the Second Amendment under the U.S. Supreme Court’s framework in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022).

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier initially defended the law. A September 2025 brief from his office argued that the statute was constitutional and that Morgan, as a convicted felon, was not a law-abiding citizen.

Then in February 2026, Uthmeier reversed course. In a brief confessing error filed on February 13, 2026, the AG argued that the Second Amendment lets the government disarm felons whose convictions show they are dangerous, but does not support a blanket ban on every felon regardless of whether the offense involved violence. A supplemental brief filed on March 18, 2026 applied the Bruen test to argue that disarming nondangerous felons is inconsistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. No Florida Attorney General had taken that position before. The Florida Prosecuting Attorneys Association sought leave on March 27, 2026 to file an amicus brief opposing that position, arguing that felon disarmament is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition. As of September 2026 the First DCA has not ruled.

What this means for you right now: nothing has changed. The First DCA has not ruled. Florida’s Prosecuting Attorneys Association has opposed the AG’s position. Section 790.23 remains fully enforceable, and people are still being arrested and charged under it every week. If you are a convicted felon holding a firearm today because you expect the law to change, you are risking a second-degree felony and serious prison time on a legal theory no court has adopted yet.

There is one distinction worth understanding, because it explains why this is still an open question. Every Florida appellate decision upholding Section 790.23 so far, most recently Villarreal v. State, No. 6D2024-2157 (Fla. 6th DCA June 5, 2026), and before that Gibbs v. State (Fla. 3d DCA 2025) and Edenfield v. State, 379 So. 3d 5 (Fla. 1st DCA 2023), rejected a facial challenge, meaning an argument that the statute is unconstitutional in every application. The Attorney General’s position in Morgan is an as-applied challenge: that the statute is unconstitutional as applied to this particular nondangerous defendant. Villarreal expressly declined to decide that question. So while no Florida court has adopted the as-applied argument, none has rejected it either. One practical warning from Villarreal: the defendant’s as-applied claim failed because it was not preserved in the trial court. If this argument matters to your case, it has to be raised early and correctly, at the trial level, or it is gone on appeal.

Common Defenses in Felon-in-Possession Cases

The facts of the case determine the defense. These are the approaches that come up most often:

• Challenging the search. Many felon-in-possession charges begin with a traffic stop or a search of a home or vehicle. If officers conducted an unlawful search or lacked probable cause for the stop, the firearm can be excluded through a motion to suppress. As a former police academy instructor, Rocky Brancato trained officers on the procedures they are supposed to follow during stops and searches. That training informs how our attorneys examine what actually happened before the gun was found.
  
• Disputing possession. In constructive possession cases, the state has to prove you knew the firearm was there and could control it. When the gun was in a shared space, such as a vehicle with several occupants or a home with several residents, that burden gets harder to carry.
  
• Challenging the underlying conviction. If the prior felony that triggers the ban was itself defective, reversed on appeal, or resolved with a withhold of adjudication, the prosecution’s case can collapse at its foundation. Under Clarke v. United States, a Florida withhold is not a conviction for purposes of Section 790.23 at all.
  
• Arguing a statutory exception. A weapon that qualifies as an antique under Florida’s definitions falls outside the reach of 790.23. After State v. Weeks, 202 So. 3d 1 (Fla. 2016), that category is broader than most people assume. See the muzzleloader question below.
  

Rocky Brancato served as Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where he oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys. That system-level view of how charging decisions get made in gun cases shapes how the firm evaluates them from the first phone call.

In felon-in-possession cases charged alongside a drug offense, one of the first questions is whether the firearm allegation actually fits the statute the State charged under. Reading the statute against the facts, rather than accepting the State’s characterization of them, is often where the case turns.

Our defense team has also worked with forensic firearms experts to challenge weapon identification and the reliability of the state’s physical evidence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a nonviolent felon own a gun in Florida?

Not under current law. Florida Statute 790.23 does not distinguish between violent and nonviolent felonies. If you have any felony conviction, the ban applies to you. The Florida Attorney General has argued in the Morgan v. State appeal that this categorical approach is unconstitutional for nondangerous felons, but no court has yet decided that as-applied question. Florida’s appellate courts have so far rejected only facial challenges, most recently in Villarreal v. State (Fla. 6th DCA June 5, 2026). Until a court rules or the legislature acts, all felons are prohibited from possessing firearms in Florida.

Can a felon have a gun in their home in Florida?

No. The statute prohibits a convicted felon from having a firearm in their care, custody, possession, or control. A gun stored in your home is under your control. That is constructive possession, and it violates Section 790.23. Constructive possession carries the same 15-year maximum as actual possession, though it does not trigger the 3-year mandatory minimum.

Can a felon’s spouse own a gun in Florida?

Florida law does not prohibit a felon’s spouse from owning a firearm. The spouse has an independent right to possess firearms if they are not otherwise disqualified. The risk comes from access. If prosecutors can establish that the felon knew the gun was in the home and could exercise dominion and control over it, a constructive possession charge is possible. Storing the firearm in a locked safe the felon cannot open reduces that risk, but the specifics of the living arrangement matter enough to be worth a conversation with a defense attorney.

What is constructive possession of a firearm?

Constructive possession means a firearm is not on your person but sits in a place you control, you know it is there, and you have the ability to exercise dominion over it. The state must prove both knowledge and control. Being in the same room or the same vehicle as a firearm is not enough by itself.

Can a felon own a muzzleloader in Florida?

Often, yes. Florida’s antique firearm exception covers any firearm manufactured in or before 1918, any replica of one regardless of when the replica itself was made, and any firearm using fixed ammunition manufactured in or before 1918 that is no longer commercially available. In State v. Weeks, 202 So. 3d 1 (Fla. 2016), a convicted felon was prosecuted for possessing a modern muzzleloading rifle fitted with a scope. The Florida Supreme Court held that what makes a firearm a “replica” is its ignition or firing system, meaning matchlock, flintlock, percussion cap or similar, and that modern accessories like a scope do not remove it from the exception. Most percussion-ignition muzzleloaders therefore fall outside the definition of “firearm” in Section 790.001(6). Two cautions: antique status is an affirmative defense you have to raise, and the exception disappears if the weapon is used in the commission of a crime. Check with an attorney before purchasing or possessing one.

How long does the clemency process take in Florida?

The minimum wait before you can apply is 8 years after completing all terms of your sentence. After you file, the wait for a hearing can run considerably longer because of the backlog at the Executive Clemency Board. Attorneys who file these applications routinely describe three to twelve years from filing to decision for firearm authority, because every firearm application requires an investigation by the Florida Commission on Offender Review and a hearing before the Clemency Board, which meets only four times a year. There is no guaranteed timeline, and approval is not guaranteed even after a hearing. Clemency is an executive process rather than a court process, and our firm does not handle these petitions. The Office of Executive Clemency at (850) 488-2952 is the starting point.

Talk to a Tampa Gun Crimes Defense Attorney

If you are facing a felon-in-possession charge in Tampa Bay, we can evaluate your situation and tell you what the realistic paths forward look like. If you are looking for help restoring firearm rights, we are not the right firm for that. That process is mainly political rather than legal, and the clemency section above explains why and where it actually starts.

The Brancato Law Firm defends clients charged with gun crimes from our Tampa office, serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties. We track the Second Amendment developments that affect our clients, including the Florida open carry ruling.

Call (813) 727-7159 for a free consultation, or contact us online to discuss your case. A felon-in-possession arrest moves quickly toward a filing decision, and the window to influence that decision is measured in weeks. The attorneys of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato, can be reached at (813) 727-7159.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602

(813) 727-7159

Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

I’m Rocky Brancato, founder of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm. I taught search and seizure at the police academy, and most of the gun cases our attorneys defend begin exactly there — with a stop, a frisk, or a car search that has to survive the Fourth Amendment before any gun charge can.

Can You Carry a Concealed Gun Without a Permit in Florida?

Yes — since July 1, 2023, Florida is a permitless-carry state. Under section 790.01, Florida Statutes, a person may carry a concealed weapon or firearm if they are either licensed or unlicensed but otherwise satisfy the criteria for receiving and keeping a concealed-carry license — essentially, an adult who could lawfully get the license may carry without ever applying for it.

The crimes that remain: a person who is unlicensed and ineligible for a license commits a first-degree misdemeanor for carrying a concealed weapon, and a third-degree felony — up to five years — for carrying a concealed firearm. And here is what the arrest reports rarely mention:

Section 790.01(4) puts that burden expressly on the State: it must prove, as elements, both that you were unlicensed and that you were ineligible under the license criteria. Officers in the field often cannot know either fact — which affects not just the charge but the legality of the stop itself. The statute even contains a hurricane-state exception: lawful gun owners may carry concealed while evacuating during the first 48 hours of a mandatory evacuation order.

Is Open Carry Legal in Florida Now?

As of late 2025, yes — for people who may lawfully possess firearms. In McDaniels v. State, No. 1D2023-0533 (Fla. 1st DCA Sept. 10, 2025), Florida’s First District held the state’s decades-old open-carry ban, section 790.053, unconstitutional under the Second Amendment: applying the U.S. Supreme Court’s Bruen test, the court found no historical tradition supporting a categorical ban, declaring that “[t]he Constitution protects the right to carry arms openly for self-defense.” The Attorney General directed that the ruling be honored statewide, and other districts have since acknowledged it. We broke the decision down in detail — including what it does not change — in our guide to Florida’s 2025 open-carry ruling.

The critical caveats: McDaniels protects ordinary, law-abiding adults. It does not restore gun rights to convicted felons or others prohibited from possession, it does not eliminate location restrictions, and it does not license waving a gun around — which brings us to the charge that has quietly become the workhorse of Tampa Bay gun prosecutions.

What Is Improper Exhibition of a Firearm?

Under section 790.10, Florida Statutes, exhibiting a firearm or other weapon “in a rude, careless, angry, or threatening manner,” in the presence of one or more persons and not in necessary self-defense, is a first-degree misdemeanor — up to a year in jail. In the permitless-carry era, this is the charge that turns a traffic dispute, a neighbor feud, or an argument in a parking lot into a criminal case: carrying the gun was legal; how it was displayed is what gets charged.

The defense terrain is favorable. “Rude, careless, angry, or threatening” is in the eye of an alarmed complainant; the statute itself excludes displays in necessary self-defense; and the line between lawful open carry, a defensive display, and improper exhibition is now genuinely unsettled after McDaniels. Where the display escalates into a charge of aggravated assault, remember what our assault guide explains: aggravated assault was removed from 10-20-Life in 2016, so the automatic firearm minimums people fear do not apply to that charge.

What Is Felon in Possession of a Firearm?

The most unforgiving gun crime in Florida. Under section 790.23, Florida Statutes, a convicted felon may not own or have in his or her “care, custody, possession, or control” any firearm, ammunition, or electric weapon — and the same ban reaches people found delinquent of felony-level acts who are under 24. It is a second-degree felony punishable by up to 15 years, and under the 10-20-Life statute, actual possession carries a 3-year mandatory minimum.

Three battlegrounds decide these cases. First, actual versus constructive possession: a gun in a shared car or house is not automatically “possessed” by the felon in the room — constructive possession requires proof of knowledge and dominion, it is hotly litigable, and the 3-year minimum attaches only to actual possession. Second, the search: these charges almost always begin with a stop or search that can be challenged. Third, the predicate: the ban does not apply if civil rights and firearm authority have been restored or the record was expunged — and whether an out-of-state disposition even qualifies as a “conviction” is a legal question worth litigating. Courts are also actively wrestling with Second Amendment challenges to felon-possession bans after Bruen; that litigation is moving, and preserving the issue can matter.

What Is Florida’s 10-20-Life Law?

Section 775.087(2), Florida Statutes imposes escalating mandatory minimums when a firearm is involved in one of its enumerated felonies:

The enumerated felonies include murder, robbery, burglary, kidnapping, aggravated battery, carjacking, home-invasion robbery, drug trafficking, and others — but not aggravated assault, which the Legislature removed in 2016. These minimums strip judges of discretion, which transfers all the power to the charging decision — and that is precisely where early defense work pays: whether the felony charged is actually a listed one, whether possession was “actual,” and whether the discharge caused the harm are all questions that decide decades.

Where Are Guns Still Prohibited?

Permitless carry and McDaniels changed who may carry and how — not where. The license statute’s list of prohibited places (schools and school events, courthouses, polling places, bars’ alcohol-service areas, and more) still applies to carriers, licensed or not, and separate statutes cover school zones and other sensitive locations. Location-based gun charges are technical, and signage, boundaries, and knowledge requirements all matter — do not assume a place restriction was valid just because a citation says so.

How Do We Defend Gun Charges?

We start with the stop. Most Tampa Bay gun cases begin with a traffic stop, a street encounter, or an anonymous tip — and after permitless carry, the sight of a firearm, without more, is a weak foundation for a detention. I taught officers this area of law at the police academy; our attorneys use that training to find the constitutional defects in how the gun was found. From there: the State’s burden to prove license ineligibility as an element; actual-versus-constructive possession in every multi-occupant case; the necessary-self-defense exclusion in exhibition cases; predicate and restoration issues in felon-possession cases; and the charging-precision fights that keep 10-20-Life minimums out of the case. Gun charges carry the harshest math in Florida sentencing — the defense has to start before the math does.

What Should You Do If You Are Arrested on a Gun Charge?

Say nothing about the gun — not whose it is, not why it was there, not that you “didn’t know it was still in the bag.” Possession cases are built on statements more often than fingerprints. Then move fast: the stop and search that produced the firearm are the foundation of the case, and the video, witnesses, and dispatch records that test them are freshest in the first weeks. If you are a prior felon, bring your complete history — including any rights restoration — to counsel immediately, because the difference between a defensible case and a 3-year minimum can be one document. Our attorneys evaluate the search first, the possession theory second, and the plea posture last.

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Gun Crimes

Do I need a permit to carry a gun in Florida?

Not for concealed carry, since July 1, 2023 — anyone who meets the criteria to get a concealed-carry license may carry without one. Carrying while ineligible remains a crime (a third-degree felony for a concealed firearm), and the license itself still has benefits, including reciprocity in other states. Our attorneys still see arrests of eligible carriers; eligibility is an element the State must prove, and we hold it to that.

Is open carry legal in Florida?

Yes, as of the First District’s September 2025 decision in McDaniels v. State declaring the open-carry ban unconstitutional — a ruling honored statewide. It applies to people who may lawfully possess firearms, it leaves location restrictions intact, and it does not protect angry or threatening displays, which remain chargeable as improper exhibition. Our detailed guide to the ruling covers what changed and what did not.

Can a convicted felon ever have a gun again in Florida?

Only after civil rights and firearm authority are restored through clemency, or if the record was expunged under the specific statute — otherwise possession of a firearm or even ammunition is a second-degree felony. Whether a particular old disposition actually qualifies as a predicate conviction is a genuine legal question, and The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. examines it in every felon-possession case.

What is the penalty for carrying a concealed firearm without being eligible?

A third-degree felony — up to five years in prison. But the State must prove both that you were unlicensed and that you were ineligible for a license, as elements of the crime. Many arrests are made without officers knowing either fact, which creates both trial defenses and suppression issues.

Does pulling a gun trigger 10-20-Life?

Displaying a gun, without firing it, is typically charged as improper exhibition (a misdemeanor) or aggravated assault (a felony) — and aggravated assault is not on the 10-20-Life list. The 10-, 20-, and 25-to-life minimums attach when a firearm is possessed or discharged during one of the statute’s enumerated felonies, like robbery or burglary. Which charge gets filed is a decision our attorneys work to influence early.

Can gun charges be dismissed?

Regularly — gun cases rise and fall on the stop and search, and a suppressed firearm usually ends the prosecution. Possession theories fail in shared spaces, eligibility elements go unproven, and self-defense excludes exhibition charges. The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. defends firearm cases throughout Tampa Bay — call (813) 727-7159 for a free, confidential review before you talk to anyone about the gun.

For more about our defense strategies, visit our Hillsborough County Criminal Defense Attorney page.

Related reading: Florida’s 2025 Open-Carry Ruling: What You Need to Know · What Is Assault in Florida? · What Is Robbery in Florida? · What Is Burglary in Florida? · What to Do After Being Arrested in Tampa, Florida

Florida Gave You More Gun Rights — and Kept Every Gun Charge

If you have been arrested on a firearm charge in Hillsborough, Pinellas, or Pasco County, you are caught in the gap between a state that just expanded carry rights and prosecutors still charging every gun they find. Call the attorneys of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. — founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato — at (813) 727-7159 before you give a statement. The search that found the gun is the case; let us test it while the evidence is fresh.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.