At The Brancato Law Firm, we take a different approach. Lead attorney Rocky Brancato has tried over 150 jury cases to verdict across homicide,sex crimes, child abuse, and violent felonies during 25+ years of exclusive criminal defense. We prepare every case as if it will go before a jury, and that level of preparation is what creates real leverage, whether your case ends in a dismissal, a negotiated resolution, or a trial verdict.

Why So Few Criminal Cases in Florida Go to Trial

Pew Research Center data, drawn from the National Center for State Courts, shows that Florida’s criminal jury-trial rate sits at just 1.53%. 

Roughly 98% of criminal cases in Florida are resolved without a jury through plea agreements, dismissals, or diversion programs.

The National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers calls the gap between plea offers and post-trial sentences the “trial penalty.” 

The Florida Bar’s Criminal Law Section has openly debated the institutional pressure on judges and prosecutors to move cases through the system as quickly as possible.

This creates a real problem for defendants. When your attorney’s primary strategy is negotiating a plea, prosecutors have little incentive to offer favorable terms. They know your attorney won’t push the case to trial, so they don’t have to.

What Happens When Your Attorney Only Negotiates

Some defense attorneys in the Tampa Bay area present themselves as trial lawyers but focus almost exclusively on negotiating plea deals. They may resolve cases quickly, but often before they have fully challenged the State’s evidence. This approach can leave you vulnerable and close the door on a potential dismissal or a more favorable resolution.

Choosing a criminal trial attorney who actually prepares for trial changes the dynamic entirely.

The Brancato Law Firm’s Two-Track Defense System

The Brancato Law Firm’s Trial-First Defense Approach

We are trial-ready, not deal-ready. Every case we take is prepared as if the trial is the destination.

• Trial Preparation from Day One. We assume nothing and immediately begin building a robust trial strategy. Our team prepares for a jury trial by filing motions to suppress evidence, challenging forensic conclusions, deposing witnesses, and issuing subpoenas for records the State would rather we not see. Rocky Brancato spent roughly 24 years at the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, rising to Chief Operations Officer where he oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys and 200+ total employees. That institutional knowledge of how the criminal justice system works, from charging policies to courtroom procedure, shapes how we build every case.

• A Reputation Prosecutors Already Know. Preparation alone is only part of the equation. Prosecutors in Hillsborough County know our firm and they know our track record across 150+ jury trials. When The Brancato Law Firm is on a case file, they don’t learn that we will be ready for trial. They already know it. That reputation creates immediate pressure for the State to honestly evaluate whether their evidence can survive cross-examination and forensic scrutiny.

How Trial Readiness Protects You in Tampa

Our preparation pressures the State to evaluate their case knowing we are prepared to expose any flaw in their arguments in open court. This is why trial readiness matters even when a case never goes to trial. It puts you in a position of strength at every stage.

When a favorable resolution is possible, our preparation is the reason it’s favorable. When trial is the only way to protect your rights, we are ready. We handle criminal defense across homicide, sex crimes, DUI, domestic violence, drug crimes, weapons offenses, child abuse, and violent crimes, and every case receives the same trial-level preparation.

The pressure to plead guilty is real. Defendants who exercise their right to trial sometimes face harsher sentences than what was offered in a plea, a concept known as vindictive sentencing or the “trial tax.” The best defense against this pressure is an attorney whose trial record makes prosecutors take the case seriously from the start.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a plea negotiator and a criminal trial attorney in Tampa?

A plea negotiator focuses primarily on reaching a deal with the prosecution, often without fully testing the State’s evidence. A criminal trial attorney prepares every case for trial by filing motions, challenging forensic evidence, deposing witnesses, and building a complete defense strategy. That preparation gives your attorney stronger negotiating leverage because the prosecution knows your attorney can and will go to trial if the offer is not fair.

Do most criminal cases in Florida go to trial?

No. Fewer than 2% of criminal cases in Florida are decided by a jury, according to data from the National Center for State Courts. The remaining cases are resolved through plea agreements, dismissals, or diversion programs. This is why choosing an attorney who actually prepares for trial matters. When prosecutors know your attorney is unlikely to try the case, they have less incentive to offer a favorable resolution.

Talk to a Tampa Criminal Trial Attorney Today

If you are facing criminal charges in the Tampa Bay area, you need a defense team whose trial record speaks for itself. The Brancato Law Firm brings 150+ jury trials to verdict, 25+ years of exclusive criminal defense experience, and death-penalty-qualified trial preparation to every case.

Call (813) 727-7159 for a free, confidential consultation. We are available 24/7 for arrest emergencies.

Most people assume that going to trial dramatically increases their sentencing risk. Under Florida’s Criminal Punishment Code (CPC), this is often true. However, there’s one critical exception that completely flips the strategic analysis: when your lowest permissible sentence already exceeds the statutory maximum for your offense.

In these cases, you cannot receive a harsher sentence by going to trial. If the prosecution refuses to offer a deal below your LPS, and your lawyer doesn’t understand this leverage, you surrender the biggest strategic advantage the law provides.

Trial vs. Plea: When the Math Changes

How the Criminal Punishment Code Works

Under Florida’s CPC, every felony case generates a scoresheet that calculates a mandatory Lowest Permissible Prison Sentence (LPS). This LPS represents the minimum a judge must impose unless there’s an authorized reason to depart from the guidelines.

In cases involving serious offenses, multiple counts, or extensive prior records, the LPS can climb above the standard statutory maximum. For example, a third-degree felony normally carries a five-year maximum. But if your scoresheet calculates an LPS of 12 years, something important happens: the LPS becomes the maximum.

Florida appellate courts, including the Supreme Court, have consistently reinforced this principle:

“When the statutory maximum sentence as provided in section 775.082, Florida Statutes, is exceeded by the lowest permissible sentence under the code, the lowest permissible sentence under the code becomes the maximum sentence which the trial judge can impose.”

Recent Case: Harris v. State (2025)

The trial judge sentenced Harris to 15 years—but his LPS was only 154.950 months. The Fifth DCA vacated the sentence because it exceeded the legal maximum. This case demonstrates both the rule and what happens when judges violate it.

What This Means for Your Defense Strategy

When your LPS exceeds the statutory maximum, several powerful strategic realities emerge:

1. Plea Advantage Disappears: If the State refuses to offer a sentence below your LPS, that plea provides zero reduction in your sentencing exposure.
2. Trial Risk Neutralized: Going to trial doesn’t increase your sentencing exposure because the post-conviction sentence is capped by the LPS.
3. “Trial Penalty” Eliminated: The traditional fear of receiving a harsher sentence for exercising your right to trial vanishes.
4. Leverage Shifts to Defense: You have everything to gain by going to trial—seeking acquittal, dismissal, or reversal—and nothing additional to lose on sentencing.

Why Your Lawyer Must Understand This Analysis

This CPC analysis separates true major-felony trial lawyers from attorneys who primarily handle high-volume dockets or rely on plea bargaining. Only a lawyer who understands this nuance will:

• Immediately calculate the LPS from the CPC Scoresheet
• Compare the LPS to the statutory maximum and recognize when LPS controls
• Confront the State with this reality: their offer provides no actual incentive if it’s not below the LPS
• Prepare for trial knowing the client’s sentencing risk is identical to the best offer being made

Without a lawyer who executes this analysis, defendants are often pressured into accepting pleas that offer zero benefit compared to post-trial sentencing risk.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a plea offer above the LPS worthless?

Yes. A plea that doesn’t go below the lowest permissible sentence gives you nothing you wouldn’t also face after conviction at trial. The only value in a plea is guaranteed sentence reduction.

Can I really get more time for going to trial in this situation?

Not legally. When your LPS exceeds the statutory maximum, the judge cannot sentence you to more than the LPS—even after trial conviction.

What is the “trial penalty” or “trial tax”?

The trial penalty is the extra time a defendant may receive after losing at trial compared to a plea offer. In theory, judges shouldn’t impose harsher sentences just because someone exercised their right to trial—but in practice, the gap between plea offers and post-trial sentences can be significant. When LPS exceeds statutory max, this penalty disappears.

If the prosecutor refuses to negotiate below LPS, should I go to trial?

When the prosecutor refuses to offer a sentence below the LPS, your sentencing exposure is identical at trial. Their refusal removes the only leverage a plea might provide, making trial a rational strategic choice to seek acquittal or dismissal.

Do I have to go to trial?

Not necessarily. In many cases, prosecutors will negotiate once they know your attorney is fully prepared to fight. When the State realizes trial is a real possibility, they may agree to a significant departure from guidelines or offer a resolution they’d never consider for an attorney who only pleads cases. A strong trial posture often creates better plea options—sometimes far better than what was originally offered.

Does This Apply to Your Case?

Understanding whether your LPS exceeds the statutory maximum requires careful scoresheet analysis. If it does, you may have leverage your current attorney hasn’t identified—leverage that could change everything about how your case should be handled.

I’m Tampa Attorney Rocky Brancato. For over 25 years, I have tried major felony cases throughout Tampa Bay. I understand the Criminal Punishment Code, the case law that governs it, and how to use this technical leverage to force better outcomes for clients.

Call (813) 727-7159 for a Case Evaluation

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

620 E Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602