How to Fight an Insurance Fraud Charge in Florida? (2026)

Rocky Brancato

To fight an insurance fraud charge in Florida, the defense attacks intent and materiality: under section 817.234, the State must prove you knowingly gave an insurer false or misleading information about a fact that mattered to the claim, and that you did it with intent to injure, defraud, or deceive. The insurer does not have to pay or believe the claim for the charge to stand. The degree depends on the value involved, from a third-degree felony under $20,000 to a first-degree felony at $100,000 or more, and staged crashes carry a two-year mandatory minimum.

A prosecutor in an insurance fraud case has to prove what was in your head when you filled out a claim form or answered an adjuster’s questions. I have spent more than 25 years in Hillsborough County courtrooms testing exactly that kind of proof, including as former Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where I oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys. As founder of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm, I have tried more than 150 jury trials to verdict, and our attorneys defend insurance fraud cases from the first call by a state investigator through trial.

What is insurance fraud under Florida law?

Insurance fraud in Florida is knowingly giving an insurer false, incomplete, or misleading information about a material fact, with intent to injure, defraud, or deceive the insurer. The crime is defined in section 817.234, Florida Statutes, and it covers claims under auto, homeowners, health, workers’ compensation, life, and other policies, along with HMO contracts. It also covers lies on an application for a policy or for a lower premium, such as hiding a driver in the household or listing a false garaging address. Our firm handles these cases alongside the other fraud and property offenses on our Tampa theft and property crimes attorney page.

Common fact patterns we see include a vehicle reported stolen that was actually sold or wrecked, a homeowner’s claim padded with items that were never in the house, a PIP claim for treatment that never happened, and an injury claim that hides an earlier accident. Each one turns on the same two questions: was the statement false or misleading, and did the person know it and mean to deceive?

What does the State have to prove in an insurance fraud case?

The State has to prove each element of section 817.234(1)(a) beyond a reasonable doubt. For the most common charge, presenting a false claim, those elements are:

Elements of insurance fraud under section 817.234(1)(a)1.
ElementWhat it meansWhere the defense looks
StatementYou presented, or caused someone to present, a written or oral statement as part of a claimWho actually filled out or submitted the claim, and whether you saw it
False or misleadingThe statement contained false, incomplete, or misleading informationWhether the information was wrong at all, or just imprecise or disputed
Material factThe information concerned a fact or thing material to the claimWhether the fact could have changed coverage or the amount paid
KnowledgeYou knew the statement contained false or misleading informationMistakes, memory gaps, language barriers, and answers filled in by others
IntentYou acted with intent to injure, defraud, or deceive the insurerCorrections you made, cooperation with the adjuster, and innocent explanations

The 2021 decision in State v. Delprete, 331 So. 3d 174 (Fla. 4th DCA 2021) shows how courts read these elements. Delprete twice told his insurer his car had been stolen and that he was not driving when it crashed, even though the police report said he was the driver. The trial court dismissed the charge because the insurer never relied on his story. The Fourth District reversed, holding that reliance is not an element of the crime and that whether his statements were material was a question for the jury. The lesson is direct: the fact that the insurer saw through the claim, or never paid it, does not end the case.

How much prison time does insurance fraud carry in Florida?

Insurance fraud is always a felony in Florida, and the degree depends on the value of the property involved. Section 817.234(11) sets the degree, and section 775.082 sets the maximum prison term for each degree.

Florida insurance fraud penalties by value and type of charge
ChargeDegreeMaximum prisonMaximum fine
Claim or application fraud, value under $20,000Third-degree felony5 years$5,000
Claim or application fraud, $20,000 to under $100,000Second-degree felony15 years$10,000
Claim or application fraud, $100,000 or moreFirst-degree felony30 years$10,000
Soliciting accident victims with intent to defraud, s. 817.234(8)(a)Second-degree felony, 2-year mandatory minimum15 years$10,000
Staged crash or fake crash paperwork for a PIP or tort claim, s. 817.234(9)Second-degree felony, 2-year mandatory minimum15 years$10,000

Value is often where the State overreaches. Prosecutors sometimes charge the full amount of a claim when only one line item is alleged to be false, which can push a case from a third-degree felony into the second-degree range. Our attorneys pull the claim file, separate the disputed items from the legitimate ones, and argue for the degree the evidence actually supports.

A conviction also carries civil exposure. Under section 817.234(5), an insurer damaged by the fraud can sue for compensatory damages plus investigation costs and attorney fees once there has been a criminal adjudication of guilt. That is one reason the form of any plea matters.

How does an insurance fraud investigation start in Florida?

Most insurance fraud cases start with the insurance company, not the police. An insurer’s special investigations unit flags the claim and refers it to the Florida Department of Financial Services, whose investigators decide whether to open a criminal case. The volume is large: from Fiscal Year 2014-15 through 2019-20, the Division of Investigative and Forensic Services received 99,287 fraud referrals, according to OPPAGA Report No. 21-05 (March 2021), the Florida Legislature’s research office. That same report found that most suspected fraud referrals were closed without becoming a fraud case because they lacked sufficient evidence to proceed.

The cases that do move forward lead to real arrests. The Department of Financial Services reported in July 2026 that its Bureau of Insurance Fraud arrested 634 people over the prior year, out of 1,219 total arrests by its Criminal Investigations Division.

Florida insurance fraud statistics: 634 insurance fraud arrests by the DFS Bureau of Insurance Fraud in one year (Florida DFS, 2026); 1,219 arrests by DFS Criminal Investigations Division investigators (Florida DFS, 2026); 99,287 fraud referrals over fiscal years 2014-15 to 2019-20 (OPPAGA Report 21-05, 2021). How to fight an insurance fraud charge in Florida, The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

In our experience defending these cases in Hillsborough County, the first sign of a criminal case is usually a phone call or business card from a Department of Financial Services detective asking for a “quick statement” about the claim, often weeks or months after the adjuster’s examination. By then the detective already has the claim file, the recorded statement you gave the adjuster, and any examination under oath. Our representation before charges are filed starts at that call: we contact the detective, keep you from giving a second statement that can be compared line by line with the first, and present documents to the State Attorney’s Office for the 13th Judicial Circuit before a filing decision is made. Our guide to the Florida criminal case process explains each stage that follows an investigation.

How do our attorneys fight an insurance fraud charge?

Our attorneys fight insurance fraud charges by testing each element against the claim file, the recorded statements, and the people who actually handled the paperwork. The defenses that come up most often are:

  1. No intent to deceive. An honest mistake, a bad estimate of an item’s value, or a misremembered date is not fraud. We look for corrections you made on your own and for cooperation with the adjuster, which cut against intent.
  2. The statement was not material. A wrong detail that could not have changed coverage or the payout does not meet the statute. Delprete makes this a jury question, which means it is a real fight at trial.
  3. Someone else made the statement. Public adjusters, contractors, body shops, and clinic staff often fill out claim paperwork. We trace who wrote and submitted each document.
  4. Language and comprehension. Recorded statements taken in English from Spanish or Haitian Creole speakers, without a qualified interpreter, are a frequent source of “false” answers that were really misunderstandings.
  5. Value and degree. We separate disputed items from legitimate ones to challenge the felony degree.
  6. Time limits. Under section 775.15, most felonies must be charged within 3 years, and first-degree felonies within 4 years. For offenses with fraud as an element, the State can file within 1 year after the insurer discovers the fraud, but that extension can never add more than 3 years.

Attorneys and medical providers face special rules. In State v. Mark Marks, P.A., 698 So. 2d 533 (Fla. 1997), the Florida Supreme Court reviewed charges against a law firm, its attorneys, and a doctor over injury claims. The court held that section 817.234(1) applies to claims against another driver’s liability insurer, not just your own insurer, but that the word “incomplete” was unconstitutionally vague as applied to attorneys representing clients. The State can still prosecute anyone, including an attorney, for false or misleading statements.

Insurance fraud cases often travel with other charges. The State may add a scheme to defraud charge when it alleges several claims, a false report of a crime when a fake theft was reported to police, or a forgery charge when receipts or estimates were altered.

Can an insurance fraud charge be resolved without a conviction?

Yes, many first-time insurance fraud cases can be resolved without a felony conviction. In Hillsborough County, the State Attorney’s Office offers pretrial intervention for certain first-time felony offenders, supervised by the Florida Department of Corrections, and repaying the insurer is usually a central condition. Our guide to the Hillsborough County PTI program explains who qualifies. Where diversion is not available, a withhold of adjudication can avoid a formal conviction in many cases, which also matters because the insurer’s civil remedy under section 817.234(5) depends on an adjudication of guilt.

Restitution is the center of most negotiations. Insurers want their money back, and prosecutors weigh the insurer’s position heavily. Our attorneys often negotiate the repayment amount and schedule before charges are filed, which can change whether a case is filed at all and at what degree.

What should you do if an insurance investigator contacts you?

Do not give a recorded or written statement to a state investigator until you have spoken with a criminal defense attorney. The most important steps are:

  • Do not call the adjuster or investigator back to “clear things up.” Every new statement is compared with your earlier ones.
  • Do not withdraw, change, or resubmit the claim without legal advice. Changes can look like an admission.
  • Keep every document: the policy, the claim forms, photos, receipts, repair estimates, and texts with the adjuster or contractor.
  • Write down who helped you prepare the claim, such as a public adjuster, contractor, or clinic.
  • Call a defense attorney the same day the investigator calls.

Frequently asked questions about Florida insurance fraud charges

Is lying on a car insurance application a crime in Florida?

Yes. Knowingly giving false information on an application for a policy or a lower premium, or knowingly hiding a material fact, is insurance fraud under section 817.234(1)(a)3. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm look first at whether the application question was clear and whether you, or an agent, actually supplied the answer.

Can you be charged with insurance fraud if the insurance company never paid?

Yes. In State v. Delprete, the Fourth District held that reliance and payment are not elements of insurance fraud, so a claim the insurer denied can still be charged. The Brancato Law Firm uses the denial differently, as evidence on materiality and on whether the State’s value figure is inflated.

Can insurance fraud charges be dropped in Florida?

Yes. Charges can be dropped or reduced when the evidence of intent is weak, the disputed facts were not material, or the value was overstated, and some cases are diverted through pretrial intervention. Our Tampa fraud defense attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm present that evidence to the prosecutor before the filing decision whenever possible.

Is PIP fraud a felony in Florida?

Yes. A false PIP claim is a felony under section 817.234, and organizing or knowingly taking part in a staged crash or fake crash paperwork for a PIP claim is a second-degree felony with a two-year mandatory minimum under subsection (9). The Brancato Law Firm examines whether a passenger or patient actually knew the crash was staged, which is often the weakest point in the State’s case against them.

How long does the State have to file an insurance fraud charge in Florida?

Usually 3 years from the offense for second- and third-degree felonies and 4 years for first-degree felonies, under section 775.15. Because fraud is an element, the State can sometimes file within 1 year after the insurer discovers it, but never more than 3 years beyond the normal deadline; our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm calculate that date at the first meeting, using our pre-file advocacy process when no charge has been filed yet.

Will I have to pay the insurance company back if I am convicted?

Usually, yes. Courts routinely order restitution in fraud cases, and section 817.234(5) also lets the insurer sue for damages, investigation costs, and attorney fees after an adjudication of guilt. The Brancato Law Firm negotiates repayment terms as part of any resolution so the amount reflects only what the evidence supports.

For more about our defense strategies, visit our Theft and Property Crimes page.

An insurance fraud investigation can move to an arrest warrant without warning, so the time to act is before you speak with the detective. Our attorneys will review the claim file and contact the investigator for you. Call The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato, at (813) 727-7159; call us at any hour. Our office is two blocks from the courthouse. Our firm has Spanish-speaking staff, and attorney Jean-Luc Adrien speaks Spanish, Haitian Creole, and French.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jean-Luc is a Great lawyer to put your trust into

Darrin L.

Jean-luc Adrien es un excelente abogado me ayudó mucho en mi proceso y lo recomiendo. (English: Jean-Luc Adrien is an excellent lawyer. He helped me a lot with my case, and I recommend him.)

Stiven P.

Brancato Law Firm is hands down the BEST Firm in the Tampa Bay area! The move swift and fast with professionalism. I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND them to support you and your judicial needs. Jean-Luc is a GREAT attorney and would request his service if in need!

Anthony J.

One of top criminal defense lawyers, deep experience, very trustworthy. No gimic.

Mahmoud M.

Rocky is incredible! Extremely knowledgeable, excellent communication with updates as the case goes on without you having to reach out to him, and you can tell he truly cares about what he does. Would recommend this law firm to anyone! Would give 10 stars if I could. Thank you so...

Bryton Ennis

Rocky Brancato was able to provide me with legal help that I didn't even imagine was possible. Because of his experience and knowledge he got me life changing results and that is no exaggeration. Rocky has an in depth knowledge of his field, decades of experience, and...

E. M.

Rocky is the best lawyer. He believed in me when no one else did. He fought hard, and did not stop working until he found the evidence we needed to win my case and clear my name. When he took on my case, it had been already ongoing for quite some time, many other lawyers turned...

Molly G.

I highly recommend Rocky! He was professional, knowledgeable, and always available to answer our questions. He worked hard on our case and helped us achieve a great outcome. A special thanks to his assistant as well—he was incredibly friendly, helpful, and treated us like family...

Akrm E.

Mans got me outta jail he legit !!

NFG President Kay

I’m incredibly grateful for the help I received from this law firm. His knowledge and expertise were evident right away, and he handled everything in a timely and professional way. What stood out most to me was the way I was treated—with care, respect, and genuine decency...

Kristen Crotinger

I had an excellent experience working with Rocky Brancato during an extremely stressful and sensitive situation involving false allegations. From the very beginning, Rocky provided clear, sound advice and took the time to truly listen to all of my concerns without ever...

David E

Rocky is a great lawyer. He jumped on my case and provided almost instant results. He communicated well and made sure we understood our options and the next steps. 5 stars!!!

Jasmine

These folks are awesome, they addressed all my concerns and were very professional.

Willem P.

I don’t even know how to start writing this. This man saved me from something I didn’t do. He’s the best.. thank you thank you .

Jonathan S.

Mr. Brancato deserves five stars from day one. He went over and beyond for me. He doesnt just handle small cases I was facing a trafficking fentanyl charge for something that I didnt do and Mr. Brancato got all of my charges dropped. He is a great attorney. He answered any...

Andrea M

I contacted Rocky Brancato at Brancato Law Firm for guidance regarding Florida law and a potential travel matter. He was straightforward, candid, and extremely professional in his advice. I truly appreciated his honesty and clear explanation of the legal landscape. I would highly...

Kevin Marcus

Rocky Brancato is diligent, trustworthy, with an extraordinary human and professional quality, a gift for people and integrity. All these virtues make him an invaluable attorney. Rocky Brancato has been with our family since day one of this stressful, unfair, and overwhelming...

Lein L.

ROCKY IS GREAT HE DID IT TWICE FOR MY FIANCÉ

Mantha W.

I would recommend Mr. Brancato to absolutely anybody. I have been fighting this specific case for about 4 years now and he was able to set time aside to accommodate and was able to get the charges dismissed in less than a WEEK. I can’t thank him enough, and anybody in the Tampa...

Kellz C.

The rare lawyer with a heart Mr. Brancato not only proved his legal acumen, but he did so with genuine empathy and caring. I felt he was personally invested in my success, and acted above and beyond my expectations. He kept me informed all steps of the process, and was upfront...

I.

Mark my words, THIS IS THE BEST LAWYER I’ve ever had the chance to meet and it’s been a pleasure and a major blessing to have him, i had a very difficult case but in less then 5 business day he took the weight of a planet off my shoulders . He goes above and beyond and then did...

Yian V.

Great attorney ! Handled client with care and answered all concerns! Thank you so much !!! A Hard worker is this guy! Thank You for all you did for my fiancé!

Kailyn B.

Rocky Brancato was knowledgeable, responsive, and very professional throughout the entire process. I highly recommend this law firm.

Noel F.

It’s no surprise that this practice has a perfect five-star rating – and they deserve it. I live in Miami, but called Rocky after doing a Google search about my issue. Not only did he get right to the point and answer my questions, he didn’t even charge me. And - I was talking on...

Rob S.

Rocky was the best lawyer i have recieved! He always kept me updated and talked me through everything i couldnt have asked for a better lawyer! Hoping i never have to use him again but he is my go to!! Thank yu rocky it was a pleasure

Lucciano Carmelo

I had a consultation with Rocky and it was exactly what I needed. He listened carefully, gave clear, honest advice, and outlined a smart path forward. Thanks to his guidance and expertise, I now know exactly how to handle the situation. I highly recommend Rocky!

C. Cole

I felt very lucky to be represented by brancato law firm Never had any issues with communication or help with resources and made the whole process easier to navigate Very greatfull he helped me reach the best outcome

Logan Traun

Atty Rocky Brancato is an excellent attorney. He genuinely cares about his clients. You would not find anyone else as compassionate and talented as he is as a lawyer. I would 100% recommend him.

Ana R.

Rocky is an excellent attorney! He demonstrates his passion, dedication and strong work ethic for every single case he accepts. He always go that extra mile to gain his clients trust and satisfaction. Highly recommended!

Bryan N.

Great Lawyer

Joe C.

Thank you for everything!

Kali L.

Attorney Brancato was phenomenal. If I could give him more than 5 stars I would. Very professional, polite, and just overall AMAZING. The only one that actually took the time to help me with a specific case I had for the past few years. I can’t begin to thank him enough.

Keelie

Our family had a great experience with Attorney Rocky Brancato. I wish I could give him more than five stars!

Lola J.

Very thorough and willing to help. I’m glad I chose to contact this office. I always worry about being given the run around but not here I was even given a call back to be sure that he didn’t miss anything. Thanks A+

Mark D.

Rocky went out of his way to help me. he is a very good man

David N.

Attorney Rocky Brancato of the Brancato Law Firm, P.A. Delivered on short notice in our family’s time of need. Fast response, humble and affordable.

Jose V.

Visit Us

Tampa Office
620 E Twiggs St Suite #205

Tampa, FL 33602

Located minutes from the Hillsborough County Courthouse.
Map Shield Image

Contact Us Now

Free Legal Consultation (813) 727-7159

Rocky Brancato in his office in Tampa

Meet Rocky Brancato

For over 25 years, Rocky Brancato has been a prominent force in Tampa Bay’s legal arena. Rocky rose to second-in-command at Tampa Bay’s largest defense firm before launching Brancato Law Firm, P.A. As a former specialized major crimes attorney for serious offenses like...