Civil Theft Demand Letter in Florida: Should You Pay It While Your Criminal Case Is Pending? (2026)

Rocky Brancato

Short answer: You do not have to pay a Florida civil theft demand letter to resolve your criminal case, and paying it will not make the charge go away. The letter is authorized by section 772.11, Florida Statutes, which lets a store demand $200 or three times its actual damages before filing a civil lawsuit. Paying within 30 days gets you a written release from that store’s civil claim and nothing more. The bigger risk sits in the criminal case: a conviction can be used against you in the store’s civil suit, so how the criminal case ends matters more than the letter.

The envelope usually shows up a few weeks after the stop at the store. It comes on law firm letterhead, with a dollar figure and a deadline, and it reads like a bill. Many people pay it believing it settles everything. Others ignore it, believing it will expire. Both mistakes are expensive. I founded The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm, after serving as Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where I oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys. In more than 25 years in Hillsborough County courtrooms, I have seen people pay these letters and still miss the court date that mattered. Our attorneys handle both sides of these cases together, because each side affects the other.

This guide covers what the letter is, what the store can actually recover, how a plea in the criminal case can decide the civil case, how long the store has to sue, and what to do when the letter arrives.

What is a civil theft demand letter in Florida?

A civil theft demand letter is the written demand a store or other alleged theft victim must send before it can sue you under section 772.11, Florida Statutes (2026). The statute requires that “before filing an action for damages under this section, the person claiming injury must make a written demand for $200 or the treble damage amount of the person liable for damages under this section.” The letter is the store’s private claim for money, and it runs separately from the criminal case the State Attorney’s Office prosecutes.

Retail theft is the most common source, but the same statute covers any theft under chapter 812. Employers, business partners, contractors, and family members also send section 772.11 demands. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm see them arrive both before and after criminal charges are filed.

How often do stores send these letters, and do they actually sue?

They send them in volume and rarely sue. Ryan Sullivan of the University of Nebraska College of Law surveyed every state’s civil shoplifting statute in Survey of State Civil Shoplifting Statutes (2015). He found that retailers rarely file suit and instead rely on these statutes as authority for a series of demand letters, and that one collection firm representing several large retailers reported sending more than 1 million letters a year. Sullivan also found that the letters often go out while criminal charges are pending, and that many recipients believe paying will get the charges dismissed. It will not.

The criminal side remains steady in Hillsborough County. FDLE arrest data published by Florida Health CHARTS show 3,680 larceny arrests in Hillsborough County in 2024. Those counts include only physical arrests, so petit theft cases handled by a notice to appear are not in them, and many of those cases also produce a demand letter. The Brancato Law Firm treats the letter as part of the case from the first consultation.

Civil demand letter Florida by the numbers: 3,680 larceny arrests in Hillsborough County (FDLE, 2024) and more than 1 million demand letters a year sent by one collection firm (Sullivan study, 2015). The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

Will paying the demand letter make the criminal charge go away?

No. The State of Florida prosecutes the criminal case, and the store cannot drop it by accepting your money. The release section 772.11 provides covers only “further civil liability for the specific act of theft,” and only from “the person making the written demand.” The State is not a party to that release. If you pay the letter and skip your court date, the judge can issue a warrant.

Civil demand letter vs. criminal theft charge in Florida
Civil demand letterCriminal theft charge
Who brings itThe store or its collection law firmThe State Attorney’s Office
LawSection 772.11, Florida StatutesSections 812.014 and 812.015, Florida Statutes
What is at stakeMoney: three times actual damages, $200 minimum, attorney’s feesJail, fines, probation, a criminal record
Standard of proofClear and convincing evidenceBeyond a reasonable doubt
Effect of payingWritten release from that store’s civil claimNone on its own
Deadline30 days to pay for a release; 5 years to sue, extended during the criminal caseCourt dates set by the judge

Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm keep the two tracks separate on paper and coordinated in strategy.

How much can the store actually recover?

Three times its actual damages, with a $200 minimum, but only if it proves its case. Section 772.11 gives a claimant who “proves by clear and convincing evidence” that it was injured by a theft “threefold the actual damages sustained,” a minimum of $200, and attorney’s fees. Punitive damages “may not be awarded under this section.”

The math matters when the merchandise was recovered at the door. If the item went back on the shelf undamaged, the store’s actual damages are close to zero, and three times zero is zero. That leaves the $200 floor, which is why so many demands sit near it. Letters that climb with each round are asking for money the store would still have to prove in court.

The store also has to prove criminal intent. In Gasparini v. Pordomingo, 972 So. 2d 1053 (Fla. 3d DCA 2008), a business dispute over a $300,000 fee, the Third District held that “to establish a claim for civil theft, a party must prove that a conversion has taken place and that the accused party acted with criminal intent.” The court reversed the treble-damage award. A self-checkout mistake or a genuine dispute over money owed can defeat the civil claim for the same reason it defeats the criminal one.

Fees run both ways. The statute entitles the defendant to fees and costs “upon a finding that the claimant raised a claim that was without substantial fact or legal support.” The Brancato Law Firm uses that provision when a demand rests on a weak or mistaken accusation.

Can pleading guilty in the criminal case hurt you in the civil case?

Yes. A conviction can hand the store the hardest part of its civil case. Under section 772.14, Florida Statutes (2026), a “final judgment or decree rendered in favor of the state in any criminal proceeding” about the same conduct “shall estop the defendant” in the civil action. Section 775.089(8), Florida Statutes (2026) separately provides that a conviction “shall estop the defendant from denying the essential allegations of that offense in any subsequent civil proceeding.”

In plain terms, a quick plea to get the criminal case over with can stop you from denying the theft when the store sues. Neither statute says whether a no contest plea with a withhold of adjudication triggers that bar, so our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm weigh the civil exposure before any plea is entered.

The rule does not run the other way. Under section 772.15, Florida Statutes (2026), a not guilty verdict “shall be admissible in evidence, but shall not act as an estoppel against the plaintiff.” An acquittal helps in the civil case, but the store can still sue.

How the criminal outcome affects the store’s civil claim
Outcome of the criminal caseEffect on the store’s civil claim
ConvictionEstops you from denying the offense’s essential allegations (sections 772.14 and 775.089(8))
No contest plea with withhold of adjudicationNot addressed by either statute; weigh it before entering the plea
Not guilty verdictAdmissible for you, but does not bar the claim (section 772.15)
Dismissal or completed diversionNo statute treats it as an estoppel either way
Restitution orderedSet off against any later civil recovery (section 775.089)

These questions come up at the plea stage, which our Florida criminal case process guide explains step by step.

How long does the store have to sue you?

Five years, plus however long the criminal case lasts, plus two more years. Under section 772.17, Florida Statutes (2026), a civil action may be filed “within 5 years” after the conduct ends or the claim accrues. If the State prosecutes the same conduct, the limitations period “shall be suspended during the pendency of such prosecution” and “for 2 years following its termination.”

Ignoring the letter does not run out the clock. A store that receives no payment can wait until the criminal case ends and still have years to file. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm factor that timeline into the advice on whether to pay.

What does paying the demand get you, and what does it not?

It gets you a written release from that store’s civil claim for that one act. Section 772.11 says a person who “complies with such demand within 30 days after receipt” shall be given a written release “for the specific act of theft.” It does not end the criminal case, bind the State, or cover any other incident the store accuses you of.

What paying a civil demand letter in Florida does: releases that store's civil claim, covers only that one incident, must be paid within 30 days. What it does not do: end the criminal case, bind the State Attorney, or cancel your court date. The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

Restitution in the criminal case interacts with the civil claim. Under section 775.089, “the amount of such restitution shall be set off against any subsequent independent civil recovery.” If you pay restitution through the criminal case, that amount comes off a later civil award. If you pay the demand first, keep the receipt and the release, because The Brancato Law Firm will put them in front of the prosecutor and the judge when restitution is discussed.

Can a store collect from the parents of a minor?

Yes. Section 772.11 allows a claimant to “recover the damages allowed under this section from the parents or legal guardian of any unemancipated minor who lives with his or her parents or legal guardian.” That is why many demands in juvenile cases are addressed to the parents. In Hillsborough County, many first juvenile theft incidents are handled through a JAAP civil citation instead of an arrest, but the store’s civil claim against the parents is separate from that. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm handle the juvenile case and the parents’ civil exposure together.

What should you do when a civil demand letter arrives?

Take five steps, in this order:

  1. Check your court date first. The criminal case controls your freedom; the letter controls only money. Missing court because you paid the letter can lead to a warrant.
  2. Do not call or write the store’s law firm yourself. Anything you say to them is not privileged, and an explanation written to a collection firm can end up in the prosecutor’s file.
  3. Note the 30-day window. Write down the date you received the letter. The release is available only for payment within 30 days of receipt.
  4. Do not plead in the criminal case without weighing the civil side. A conviction can be used against you in the store’s suit.
  5. Keep every document. Keep the letter, the envelope, any receipt, and any release. They matter for restitution and for any later lawsuit.

In Hillsborough County, many first-time theft cases can be resolved through diversion: the Adult Pre-Arrest Diversion program, the Misdemeanor Intervention Program, or Pretrial Intervention. A case that ends in completed diversion leaves no conviction for the store to use, which is often worth more than anything decided about the letter. Our Hillsborough County criminal defense attorneys sequence the two cases so the criminal outcome protects you on the civil side. For the elements, penalties, and defenses in the theft case itself, see our guide on how to fight a theft charge in Florida, and for value disputes, how the State proves value in a grand theft case.

Frequently asked questions about civil theft demand letters in Florida

Can a store still sue me if my shoplifting charge was dropped?

Yes. A dismissal does not bar the civil claim, and even a not guilty verdict does not estop the store under section 772.15. The Brancato Law Firm uses the weaknesses that ended the criminal case to push back on the demand.

Can I get a civil demand letter before I am charged with a crime?

Yes. Section 772.11 does not require a criminal charge or conviction, so a letter can arrive while police are still investigating. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm offer representation before charges are filed so that how you answer the letter does not help build the criminal case.

Can I negotiate a lower amount on a civil demand letter?

Often, yes. The statute sets what the store must demand before suing, and nothing in section 772.11 stops the parties from settling for less with a written release. The Brancato Law Firm can handle that contact so you do not speak to the collection firm yourself.

Does paying a civil demand letter count as admitting guilt?

Paying is not a plea and does not create a conviction. What you write or say to the store’s lawyers is not protected the way your conversations with your own lawyer are, so our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm recommend that any response go through counsel.

What if the civil theft demand comes from my employer or a business partner?

The same statute applies, and the claimant still must prove a conversion and criminal intent. In Gasparini v. Pordomingo, 972 So. 2d 1053 (Fla. 3d DCA 2008), money a business was free to use as it pleased could not support a civil theft claim. The Brancato Law Firm reviews these demands with any criminal referral in mind, since an employer’s demand often comes before a police report.

Will a civil demand letter show up on my criminal record?

No. The letter is a private civil claim and does not create a criminal record. A civil judgment, if the store sues and wins, is a public court record, and our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm explain how the civil and criminal records differ in your case.

Talk to a Tampa attorney before you answer the letter

The 30-day window on the letter and the dates in your criminal case are already running. Before you pay, call, or plead, talk to The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato. We will review the demand, weigh what each criminal outcome would mean for the store’s civil claim, and build a plan for both. Call (813) 727-7159 for a free, confidential consultation; you can call us at any hour. Our firm has Spanish-speaking staff, and attorney Jean-Luc Adrien speaks Spanish, Haitian Creole, and French.

For more on how we defend theft and property cases, visit our Hillsborough County criminal defense page.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jean-Luc is a Great lawyer to put your trust into

Darrin L.

Jean-luc Adrien es un excelente abogado me ayudó mucho en mi proceso y lo recomiendo. (English: Jean-Luc Adrien is an excellent lawyer. He helped me a lot with my case, and I recommend him.)

Stiven P.

Brancato Law Firm is hands down the BEST Firm in the Tampa Bay area! The move swift and fast with professionalism. I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND them to support you and your judicial needs. Jean-Luc is a GREAT attorney and would request his service if in need!

Anthony J.

One of top criminal defense lawyers, deep experience, very trustworthy. No gimic.

Mahmoud M.

Rocky is incredible! Extremely knowledgeable, excellent communication with updates as the case goes on without you having to reach out to him, and you can tell he truly cares about what he does. Would recommend this law firm to anyone! Would give 10 stars if I could. Thank you so...

Bryton Ennis

Rocky Brancato was able to provide me with legal help that I didn't even imagine was possible. Because of his experience and knowledge he got me life changing results and that is no exaggeration. Rocky has an in depth knowledge of his field, decades of experience, and...

E. M.

Rocky is the best lawyer. He believed in me when no one else did. He fought hard, and did not stop working until he found the evidence we needed to win my case and clear my name. When he took on my case, it had been already ongoing for quite some time, many other lawyers turned...

Molly G.

I highly recommend Rocky! He was professional, knowledgeable, and always available to answer our questions. He worked hard on our case and helped us achieve a great outcome. A special thanks to his assistant as well—he was incredibly friendly, helpful, and treated us like family...

Akrm E.

Mans got me outta jail he legit !!

NFG President Kay

I’m incredibly grateful for the help I received from this law firm. His knowledge and expertise were evident right away, and he handled everything in a timely and professional way. What stood out most to me was the way I was treated—with care, respect, and genuine decency...

Kristen Crotinger

I had an excellent experience working with Rocky Brancato during an extremely stressful and sensitive situation involving false allegations. From the very beginning, Rocky provided clear, sound advice and took the time to truly listen to all of my concerns without ever...

David E

Rocky is a great lawyer. He jumped on my case and provided almost instant results. He communicated well and made sure we understood our options and the next steps. 5 stars!!!

Jasmine

These folks are awesome, they addressed all my concerns and were very professional.

Willem P.

I don’t even know how to start writing this. This man saved me from something I didn’t do. He’s the best.. thank you thank you .

Jonathan S.

Mr. Brancato deserves five stars from day one. He went over and beyond for me. He doesnt just handle small cases I was facing a trafficking fentanyl charge for something that I didnt do and Mr. Brancato got all of my charges dropped. He is a great attorney. He answered any...

Andrea M

I contacted Rocky Brancato at Brancato Law Firm for guidance regarding Florida law and a potential travel matter. He was straightforward, candid, and extremely professional in his advice. I truly appreciated his honesty and clear explanation of the legal landscape. I would highly...

Kevin Marcus

Rocky Brancato is diligent, trustworthy, with an extraordinary human and professional quality, a gift for people and integrity. All these virtues make him an invaluable attorney. Rocky Brancato has been with our family since day one of this stressful, unfair, and overwhelming...

Lein L.

ROCKY IS GREAT HE DID IT TWICE FOR MY FIANCÉ

Mantha W.

I would recommend Mr. Brancato to absolutely anybody. I have been fighting this specific case for about 4 years now and he was able to set time aside to accommodate and was able to get the charges dismissed in less than a WEEK. I can’t thank him enough, and anybody in the Tampa...

Kellz C.

The rare lawyer with a heart Mr. Brancato not only proved his legal acumen, but he did so with genuine empathy and caring. I felt he was personally invested in my success, and acted above and beyond my expectations. He kept me informed all steps of the process, and was upfront...

I.

Mark my words, THIS IS THE BEST LAWYER I’ve ever had the chance to meet and it’s been a pleasure and a major blessing to have him, i had a very difficult case but in less then 5 business day he took the weight of a planet off my shoulders . He goes above and beyond and then did...

Yian V.

Great attorney ! Handled client with care and answered all concerns! Thank you so much !!! A Hard worker is this guy! Thank You for all you did for my fiancé!

Kailyn B.

Rocky Brancato was knowledgeable, responsive, and very professional throughout the entire process. I highly recommend this law firm.

Noel F.

It’s no surprise that this practice has a perfect five-star rating – and they deserve it. I live in Miami, but called Rocky after doing a Google search about my issue. Not only did he get right to the point and answer my questions, he didn’t even charge me. And - I was talking on...

Rob S.

Rocky was the best lawyer i have recieved! He always kept me updated and talked me through everything i couldnt have asked for a better lawyer! Hoping i never have to use him again but he is my go to!! Thank yu rocky it was a pleasure

Lucciano Carmelo

I had a consultation with Rocky and it was exactly what I needed. He listened carefully, gave clear, honest advice, and outlined a smart path forward. Thanks to his guidance and expertise, I now know exactly how to handle the situation. I highly recommend Rocky!

C. Cole

I felt very lucky to be represented by brancato law firm Never had any issues with communication or help with resources and made the whole process easier to navigate Very greatfull he helped me reach the best outcome

Logan Traun

Atty Rocky Brancato is an excellent attorney. He genuinely cares about his clients. You would not find anyone else as compassionate and talented as he is as a lawyer. I would 100% recommend him.

Ana R.

Rocky is an excellent attorney! He demonstrates his passion, dedication and strong work ethic for every single case he accepts. He always go that extra mile to gain his clients trust and satisfaction. Highly recommended!

Bryan N.

Great Lawyer

Joe C.

Thank you for everything!

Kali L.

Attorney Brancato was phenomenal. If I could give him more than 5 stars I would. Very professional, polite, and just overall AMAZING. The only one that actually took the time to help me with a specific case I had for the past few years. I can’t begin to thank him enough.

Keelie

Our family had a great experience with Attorney Rocky Brancato. I wish I could give him more than five stars!

Lola J.

Very thorough and willing to help. I’m glad I chose to contact this office. I always worry about being given the run around but not here I was even given a call back to be sure that he didn’t miss anything. Thanks A+

Mark D.

Rocky went out of his way to help me. he is a very good man

David N.

Attorney Rocky Brancato of the Brancato Law Firm, P.A. Delivered on short notice in our family’s time of need. Fast response, humble and affordable.

Jose V.

Visit Us

Tampa Office
620 E Twiggs St Suite #205

Tampa, FL 33602

Located minutes from the Hillsborough County Courthouse.
Map Shield Image

Contact Us Now

Free Legal Consultation (813) 727-7159

Rocky Brancato in his office in Tampa

Meet Rocky Brancato

For over 25 years, Rocky Brancato has been a prominent force in Tampa Bay’s legal arena. Rocky rose to second-in-command at Tampa Bay’s largest defense firm before launching Brancato Law Firm, P.A. As a former specialized major crimes attorney for serious offenses like...