What Happens When the Lowest Permissible Sentence Exceeds the Maximum in Florida? (2026)

Rocky Brancato

Fully rewritten and updated November 14, 2026. Previously updated November 8, 2026. Originally published November 22, 2025.

Short answer: When the lowest permissible sentence (LPS) on a Florida Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet is longer than the statutory maximum for an offense, the judge must impose the LPS for that offense, and the LPS also becomes the most the judge can impose for it. The Florida Supreme Court held in State v. Gabriel (2021) that the LPS is then both the minimum and the maximum for each count it exceeds. That shrinks the usual gap between a plea and a trial sentence on that count, but consecutive counts, habitual offender notices, and mandatory minimums can still raise the total, so the scoresheet has to be read count by count.

A Florida judge can sentence below the scoresheet only when the defense proves a legal reason, and can sentence above the statutory maximum only when the scoresheet itself pushes the floor past it. I have argued sentencing in Hillsborough County courtrooms for more than 25 years, including as founder of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm, and as former Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where I oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys. Our attorneys check every line of the State’s scoresheet, because a high-scoring case where the LPS passes the maximum calls for a different plea and trial strategy than an ordinary felony.

What is the lowest permissible sentence in Florida?

The lowest permissible sentence is the shortest prison term a Florida judge may impose for a felony, absent a valid reason for a downward departure. It comes from the Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet under section 921.0024, Florida Statutes. When total sentence points exceed 44, the statute subtracts 28 points and reduces the remainder by 25 percent; the result is the LPS in prison months. At 44 points or fewer, the LPS is any non-prison sanction.

Points come from the primary offense, every additional offense being sentenced, prior record, victim injury, and enhancements such as possession of a firearm. The State Attorney prepares the scoresheet, and section 921.0024(3) requires that it be presented to defense counsel to review for accuracy unless the judge directs otherwise. The sentencing judge signs it.

Total sentence pointsFormulaLowest permissible sentence
44 or fewerNo prison floorAny non-state-prison sanction
100(100 − 28) × 0.7554 months (4.5 years)
108(108 − 28) × 0.7560 months (5 years)
234.6(234.6 − 28) × 0.75154.95 months (about 12.9 years)

The last row shows how a scoresheet passes a third-degree felony cap. Any total above 108 points produces an LPS longer than five years, which is the maximum for a third-degree felony under section 775.082(3)(e).

What happens when the lowest permissible sentence exceeds the statutory maximum?

When the LPS is longer than the statutory maximum, the LPS must be imposed and it becomes the new ceiling for that offense. Section 921.0024(2) says that in this situation “the sentence required by the code must be imposed.” The Florida Supreme Court explained the other half of the rule in Butler v. State, 838 So. 2d 554 (Fla. 2003): Winyatta Butler received 75.6 months for offenses that included a third-degree cocaine possession charge with a five-year cap, and the Court held the sentence legal because, when the LPS exceeds the statutory maximum, “the lowest permissible sentence under the code becomes the maximum sentence which the trial judge can impose.”

In State v. Gabriel, 314 So. 3d 1243 (Fla. 2021), the Court resolved how the rule works with several counts. Ridge Gabriel, sentenced in Orange County, had an LPS of 107.25 months, which exceeded the five-year cap on two third-degree felonies. The Court held the comparison is made offense by offense, and that the LPS is “both the minimum sentence and the maximum penalty for that offense.” Gabriel’s two LPS sentences ran consecutively with a 15-year sentence on a second-degree count, for a total of about 33 years.

Felony degreeStatutory maximum (s. 775.082)Habitual felony offender maximum (s. 775.084)
Third degree5 years10 years
Second degree15 years30 years
First degree30 years (life where a statute provides)Life

The LPS controls only the counts whose maximum it exceeds. On a second-degree count with a 15-year cap, an LPS of 12.9 years is still a floor, and the judge can go up to 15 years.

Comparison: in a normal Florida case the lowest permissible sentence is the floor and the statutory maximum is the ceiling; when the LPS exceeds the maximum, the LPS is both floor and ceiling for that count. Watch for consecutive counts and habitual offender notices. The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

How often do Florida felony cases reach a scoresheet sentence?

Scoresheet sentencing is the normal end of a Florida felony case. The Florida Department of Corrections’ October 2025 Criminal Punishment Code report counted 85,267 scoresheets for offenders sentenced statewide from July 1, 2024 through June 30, 2025, and 21,118 of them ended in a state prison sentence. Hillsborough County accounted for 5,336 of those scoresheets, with 1,247 state prison sentences, according to the same FDC report (page 33). The report notes that its totals include only scoresheets submitted through the digitized system.

Florida sentencing by the numbers: 85,267 Criminal Punishment Code scoresheets filed statewide (FDC, FY 2024-25); 1,247 state prison sentences in Hillsborough County (FDC, FY 2024-25); 94% of state felony offenders pleaded guilty (BJS, 2006). Lowest permissible sentence guide by The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

Most of those sentences follow a plea. A Bureau of Justice Statistics study of state felony courts, Felony Sentences in State Courts, 2006, found that 94% of felony offenders sentenced in 2006 pleaded guilty, and that the average prison sentence after a trial (8 years and 4 months) was more than twice the average after a plea (3 years and 11 months). That gap is what lawyers call the trial penalty or “trial tax,” and it is the pressure an above-maximum LPS can reduce. A judge also may not punish a defendant for choosing trial, a separate protection our post on vindictive sentencing in Florida explains.

Does the trial penalty disappear when the LPS exceeds the maximum?

The trial penalty shrinks on each count where the LPS controls, but it does not always disappear from the case as a whole. On that count, a conviction after trial and a plea “as charged” both produce the same number, so a plea offer at or above the LPS buys nothing on that count. Four things can still make trial riskier than a plea:

  • Consecutive sentences. Under Gabriel, the judge can impose the LPS on each count and run them back to back, as happened to Gabriel himself. A plea can lock in concurrent time.
  • Habitual offender notice. If the State serves notice under section 775.084, a habitual felony offender can receive up to 10 years on a third-degree felony and 30 years on a second-degree felony, which moves the ceiling.
  • Mandatory minimums. A minimum mandatory term longer than the LPS, such as a drug trafficking or firearm minimum, still applies.
  • Counts the LPS does not exceed. Higher-degree counts keep their normal range up to the statutory maximum.

Our attorneys map each count before advising on any offer: which counts are capped at the LPS, which are not, whether the State has filed or could file a habitual offender notice, and what the realistic consecutive exposure is. Only then can a client compare a plea with a trial on real numbers. Our post on what happens if you reject a plea deal in Florida covers the rest of that decision.

Can a judge sentence below the lowest permissible sentence?

Yes. A judge can impose a downward departure below the LPS when the defense proves a reason allowed by section 921.0026, Florida Statutes. The statute lists mitigators that include a legitimate, uncoerced plea bargain; a relatively minor role as an accomplice; a need for specialized treatment for a mental disorder unrelated to substance abuse; and an offense committed in an unsophisticated manner as an isolated incident for which the defendant has shown remorse. The list is not exclusive.

The first mitigator is the real leverage in an above-maximum case. The State can agree to a sentence below the LPS, and that agreement is itself a lawful ground to depart. An offer at or above the LPS gives the client nothing on the capped counts, so our attorneys press for an offer below it, backed by a mitigation package and a trial-ready posture. Our guide to downward departures in Florida explains the other grounds.

What did Harris v. State and Ramos v. State decide in 2025?

Two November 2025 appellate decisions applied the rule to sentences that went past the LPS cap after jury trials. In Harris v. State, No. 5D2024-1179 (Fla. 5th DCA Nov. 21, 2025), a Volusia County jury convicted Arthur Harris of mostly drug-related offenses. His scoresheet showed an LPS of 154.950 months, but the judge imposed 15 years on two third-degree counts of attempted sale of fentanyl and attempted sale of cocaine. The Fifth District vacated both sentences because the LPS was the legal maximum, and remanded for resentencing.

In Ramos v. State, No. 6D2024-0171 (Fla. 6th DCA Nov. 14, 2025), a Charlotte County jury convicted Peter Ramos of two second-degree felonies with 15-year maximums. His LPS was 208.05 months, or 17.3375 years, yet he received 25 years on each count. The Sixth District held that the LPS “is both the minimum and maximum sentencing exposure on each count” and vacated the sentence. The lesson from both cases: an above-maximum LPS limits the judge after trial too, and a sentence past it is illegal and can be corrected on appeal or by motion.

Why does this matter in Hillsborough County cases?

Hillsborough County felony cases are sentenced in the 13th Judicial Circuit, and appeals go to the Second District Court of Appeal, which held in Champagne v. State, 269 So. 3d 629 (Fla. 2d DCA 2019) that when the LPS exceeds an offense’s statutory maximum, the LPS must be imposed for that offense. The Florida Supreme Court approved Champagne in Gabriel, so the rule binds every trial judge in the 13th Circuit. Above-maximum scoresheets show up most often in cases with a long prior record, several counts sentenced together, or victim injury points. In those cases our Hillsborough County criminal defense attorney team starts with the scoresheet, because a single scoring error of a few points can move the LPS by months or years. Drug cases often score this way; our Tampa drug crimes attorney page covers those defenses.

Frequently asked questions

Is a plea offer at the lowest permissible sentence worth taking when the LPS exceeds the maximum?

On the counts the LPS controls, a plea at the LPS gives the same sentence a conviction at trial would give. The Brancato Law Firm looks at what else the offer settles, such as concurrent time, dropped counts, or no habitual offender notice, because those terms can still make an offer worth taking. How to decide whether to accept a plea bargain walks through that comparison.

Can I get more than the lowest permissible sentence after trial if it exceeds the maximum?

Not on any single count where the LPS is higher than the statutory maximum; the LPS is both the floor and the ceiling there. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm still warn clients that several counts can run consecutively and that a habitual offender notice raises the cap, so total exposure after trial can be higher than the LPS for one count.

How do I find my lowest permissible sentence?

Your LPS is printed on the Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet the State Attorney prepares, and your lawyer is entitled to review it for accuracy. The Brancato Law Firm rechecks the offense levels, prior record entries, and victim injury points, because one wrong line can change the LPS by years. The formula is in section 921.0024.

Can a judge depart below the lowest permissible sentence when it exceeds the statutory maximum?

Yes, if the defense proves a valid mitigating reason under section 921.0026, including a legitimate plea bargain. The Brancato Law Firm builds departure motions with records, treatment history, and witness testimony, and our Hillsborough County defense team presents them at sentencing.

What if my sentence is longer than my lowest permissible sentence and the statutory maximum?

A sentence above both numbers on a single count is generally illegal and can be challenged on direct appeal or by a motion to correct an illegal sentence, as in Harris and Ramos. The Brancato Law Firm reviews the judgment, the scoresheet, and any habitual offender designation before filing, since an enhancement can make a longer sentence lawful.

Does a habitual felony offender designation change the lowest permissible sentence analysis?

Yes. A habitual felony offender sentence can reach 10 years on a third-degree felony and 30 years on a second-degree felony under section 775.084, so the LPS may no longer be the ceiling. The Brancato Law Firm checks early whether the State has served the required written notice and whether the prior convictions actually qualify.

Talk to a Tampa defense lawyer before you answer a plea offer

The scoresheet is usually final by the time of the plea conference, so the time to check it is now. Call The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato, at (813) 727-7159. Our attorneys will recalculate your lowest permissible sentence, map your exposure count by count, and tell you whether the offer on the table gives you anything. Our firm has Spanish-speaking staff, and attorney Jean-Luc Adrien speaks Spanish, Haitian Creole, and French. Call us at any hour; our office is two blocks from the courthouse.

For more about our defense strategies, visit our Hillsborough County criminal defense page. For a related sentencing issue, see our post on out-of-state jail credit in Florida.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jean-Luc is a Great lawyer to put your trust into

Darrin L.

Jean-luc Adrien es un excelente abogado me ayudó mucho en mi proceso y lo recomiendo. (English: Jean-Luc Adrien is an excellent lawyer. He helped me a lot with my case, and I recommend him.)

Stiven P.

Brancato Law Firm is hands down the BEST Firm in the Tampa Bay area! The move swift and fast with professionalism. I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND them to support you and your judicial needs. Jean-Luc is a GREAT attorney and would request his service if in need!

Anthony J.

One of top criminal defense lawyers, deep experience, very trustworthy. No gimic.

Mahmoud M.

Rocky is incredible! Extremely knowledgeable, excellent communication with updates as the case goes on without you having to reach out to him, and you can tell he truly cares about what he does. Would recommend this law firm to anyone! Would give 10 stars if I could. Thank you so...

Bryton Ennis

Rocky Brancato was able to provide me with legal help that I didn't even imagine was possible. Because of his experience and knowledge he got me life changing results and that is no exaggeration. Rocky has an in depth knowledge of his field, decades of experience, and...

E. M.

Rocky is the best lawyer. He believed in me when no one else did. He fought hard, and did not stop working until he found the evidence we needed to win my case and clear my name. When he took on my case, it had been already ongoing for quite some time, many other lawyers turned...

Molly G.

I highly recommend Rocky! He was professional, knowledgeable, and always available to answer our questions. He worked hard on our case and helped us achieve a great outcome. A special thanks to his assistant as well—he was incredibly friendly, helpful, and treated us like family...

Akrm E.

Mans got me outta jail he legit !!

NFG President Kay

I’m incredibly grateful for the help I received from this law firm. His knowledge and expertise were evident right away, and he handled everything in a timely and professional way. What stood out most to me was the way I was treated—with care, respect, and genuine decency...

Kristen Crotinger

I had an excellent experience working with Rocky Brancato during an extremely stressful and sensitive situation involving false allegations. From the very beginning, Rocky provided clear, sound advice and took the time to truly listen to all of my concerns without ever...

David E

Rocky is a great lawyer. He jumped on my case and provided almost instant results. He communicated well and made sure we understood our options and the next steps. 5 stars!!!

Jasmine

These folks are awesome, they addressed all my concerns and were very professional.

Willem P.

I don’t even know how to start writing this. This man saved me from something I didn’t do. He’s the best.. thank you thank you .

Jonathan S.

Mr. Brancato deserves five stars from day one. He went over and beyond for me. He doesnt just handle small cases I was facing a trafficking fentanyl charge for something that I didnt do and Mr. Brancato got all of my charges dropped. He is a great attorney. He answered any...

Andrea M

I contacted Rocky Brancato at Brancato Law Firm for guidance regarding Florida law and a potential travel matter. He was straightforward, candid, and extremely professional in his advice. I truly appreciated his honesty and clear explanation of the legal landscape. I would highly...

Kevin Marcus

Rocky Brancato is diligent, trustworthy, with an extraordinary human and professional quality, a gift for people and integrity. All these virtues make him an invaluable attorney. Rocky Brancato has been with our family since day one of this stressful, unfair, and overwhelming...

Lein L.

ROCKY IS GREAT HE DID IT TWICE FOR MY FIANCÉ

Mantha W.

I would recommend Mr. Brancato to absolutely anybody. I have been fighting this specific case for about 4 years now and he was able to set time aside to accommodate and was able to get the charges dismissed in less than a WEEK. I can’t thank him enough, and anybody in the Tampa...

Kellz C.

The rare lawyer with a heart Mr. Brancato not only proved his legal acumen, but he did so with genuine empathy and caring. I felt he was personally invested in my success, and acted above and beyond my expectations. He kept me informed all steps of the process, and was upfront...

I.

Mark my words, THIS IS THE BEST LAWYER I’ve ever had the chance to meet and it’s been a pleasure and a major blessing to have him, i had a very difficult case but in less then 5 business day he took the weight of a planet off my shoulders . He goes above and beyond and then did...

Yian V.

Great attorney ! Handled client with care and answered all concerns! Thank you so much !!! A Hard worker is this guy! Thank You for all you did for my fiancé!

Kailyn B.

Rocky Brancato was knowledgeable, responsive, and very professional throughout the entire process. I highly recommend this law firm.

Noel F.

It’s no surprise that this practice has a perfect five-star rating – and they deserve it. I live in Miami, but called Rocky after doing a Google search about my issue. Not only did he get right to the point and answer my questions, he didn’t even charge me. And - I was talking on...

Rob S.

Rocky was the best lawyer i have recieved! He always kept me updated and talked me through everything i couldnt have asked for a better lawyer! Hoping i never have to use him again but he is my go to!! Thank yu rocky it was a pleasure

Lucciano Carmelo

I had a consultation with Rocky and it was exactly what I needed. He listened carefully, gave clear, honest advice, and outlined a smart path forward. Thanks to his guidance and expertise, I now know exactly how to handle the situation. I highly recommend Rocky!

C. Cole

I felt very lucky to be represented by brancato law firm Never had any issues with communication or help with resources and made the whole process easier to navigate Very greatfull he helped me reach the best outcome

Logan Traun

Atty Rocky Brancato is an excellent attorney. He genuinely cares about his clients. You would not find anyone else as compassionate and talented as he is as a lawyer. I would 100% recommend him.

Ana R.

Rocky is an excellent attorney! He demonstrates his passion, dedication and strong work ethic for every single case he accepts. He always go that extra mile to gain his clients trust and satisfaction. Highly recommended!

Bryan N.

Great Lawyer

Joe C.

Thank you for everything!

Kali L.

Attorney Brancato was phenomenal. If I could give him more than 5 stars I would. Very professional, polite, and just overall AMAZING. The only one that actually took the time to help me with a specific case I had for the past few years. I can’t begin to thank him enough.

Keelie

Our family had a great experience with Attorney Rocky Brancato. I wish I could give him more than five stars!

Lola J.

Very thorough and willing to help. I’m glad I chose to contact this office. I always worry about being given the run around but not here I was even given a call back to be sure that he didn’t miss anything. Thanks A+

Mark D.

Rocky went out of his way to help me. he is a very good man

David N.

Attorney Rocky Brancato of the Brancato Law Firm, P.A. Delivered on short notice in our family’s time of need. Fast response, humble and affordable.

Jose V.

Visit Us

Tampa Office
620 E Twiggs St Suite #205

Tampa, FL 33602

Located minutes from the Hillsborough County Courthouse.
Map Shield Image

Contact Us Now

Free Legal Consultation (813) 727-7159

Rocky Brancato in his office in Tampa

Meet Rocky Brancato

For over 25 years, Rocky Brancato has been a prominent force in Tampa Bay’s legal arena. Rocky rose to second-in-command at Tampa Bay’s largest defense firm before launching Brancato Law Firm, P.A. As a former specialized major crimes attorney for serious offenses like...