How Does the Insanity Defense Work in Florida? (2026)

Rocky Brancato

Florida’s insanity defense excuses a crime only when, at the time of the act, a mental infirmity, disease, or defect kept the accused from knowing what he or she was doing or its consequences, or from knowing it was wrong. Under section 775.027, Florida Statutes, every person is presumed sane, and the defense must prove insanity by clear and convincing evidence. Written notice is due no later than 15 days after arraignment. After a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, the judge decides whether to commit the person to the Department of Children and Families, order outpatient treatment, or discharge the person.

A Florida jury can return a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity only after the defense proves, with clear and convincing evidence, that a mental illness took away the accused’s understanding of the act or of right and wrong. I’m Rocky Brancato, founder of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm. I have tried more than 150 jury trials to verdict over more than 25 years in Hillsborough County courtrooms, and I am a former Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where I oversaw a staff of over 100 attorneys. When a client’s mental illness is part of the case, our attorneys weigh insanity against competency, mental health court, and mitigation before choosing a path, because the right choice depends on the charge, the records, and what commitment would mean for that client.

This guide explains the legal test, who carries the burden, how the defense is raised under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.216, what happens after the verdict, and when another strategy works better. For the firm’s broader mental health practice, see our Tampa mental health defense attorney page.

What is the legal test for insanity in Florida?

Florida uses the M’Naghten test, written into section 775.027, Florida Statutes. The statute says insanity is established when the defendant had “a mental infirmity, disease, or defect” and, because of that condition, either did not know what he or she was doing or its consequences, or knew what he or she was doing but “did not know that what he or she was doing was wrong.” Both parts are required. A diagnosis alone is never enough.

The test looks only at the moment of the offense. A person who is stable and medicated at trial can still be found insane for an act committed during a psychotic episode months earlier, and a person who is very ill at trial can still be found sane for the act itself.

RequirementWhat the defense must showTypical proof
Mental conditionA mental infirmity, disease, or defect existed at the time of the actTreatment records, prior diagnoses, jail medical intake, expert evaluation
Effect of the conditionBecause of that condition, the person did not know what he or she was doing or its consequences, OR did not know it was wrongExpert opinion, statements and behavior at the scene, 911 calls, body camera video, family and witness testimony
The two-part insanity test under section 775.027

Who has to prove insanity, and how much proof is needed?

The defense carries the burden. Section 775.027(2) states that “the defendant has the burden of proving the defense of insanity by clear and convincing evidence,” and the statute begins from the rule that “all persons are presumed to be sane.” Clear and convincing evidence is a higher standard than the preponderance standard used in most civil cases, though lower than proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The State still has to prove every element of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt; insanity is an affirmative defense the jury reaches only after that.

The burden makes expert work the center of the case. In Rodriguez v. State, 172 So. 3d 540 (Fla. 5th DCA 2015), a man shot six people at his former employer’s Orlando office in 2009, killing one. Seven defense experts testified that he had paranoid schizophrenia and did not know right from wrong, and the State called no expert of its own. The jury still convicted. The Fifth District reversed for a new trial because the judge had added an outdated “hallucinations” instruction, which does not apply to crimes committed after section 775.027 took effect on June 19, 2000. Even an insanity case with overwhelming expert support can be lost on how the jury is instructed, so the defense has to fight over Florida Standard Jury Instruction (Criminal) 3.6(a) as hard as it fights over the evidence.

Does mental illness alone make someone legally insane?

No. Section 775.027 states that a “mental infirmity, disease, or defect does not constitute a defense of insanity except as provided in this subsection.” A person can have a serious diagnosis, such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, and still know what he or she was doing and that it was wrong in the legal sense, even if the illness shaped why the person acted.

Florida also bars what other states call diminished capacity. In Chestnut v. State, 538 So. 2d 820 (Fla. 1989), a man convicted of first-degree murder wanted experts to tell the jury about his brain damage, low intelligence, and seizure disorder to show he could not form premeditation. The Florida Supreme Court held that evidence of “an abnormal mental condition not constituting legal insanity” is not admissible to prove the accused could not form the specific intent the crime requires. In practice, mental health evidence short of insanity usually belongs at sentencing, in mitigation, or in a diversion request rather than at the guilt phase.

Drugs and alcohol are treated separately. Under section 775.051, Florida Statutes, voluntary intoxication “is not a defense to any offense,” and evidence of it “is not admissible to show that the defendant was insane at the time of the offense,” with one exception for a controlled substance taken under a lawful prescription issued to the defendant. Our post on the intoxication defense in Florida covers that rule in more detail.

How often is the insanity defense used, and how often does it work?

Rarely, and it usually fails. The largest multi-state study of insanity pleas, published by Lisa Callahan and colleagues in the Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law in 1991, hand-searched court records in eight states and found the insanity defense was raised in 1 percent of felony cases. Only 26 percent of the defendants who raised it were found not guilty by reason of insanity.

Insanity is a trial defense for a narrow group of cases where the records show severe illness at the exact time of the act. For most clients with mental illness, The Brancato Law Firm puts its effort into competency, treatment-based resolutions, and mitigation, which resolve far more cases.

How do you raise an insanity defense in a Florida criminal case?

The defense must file written notice under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.216. Without that notice, “no evidence offered by the defendant for the purpose of establishing that defense shall be admitted.” The steps our attorneys follow look like this:

  1. Gather the records first: prior treatment, Baker Act history, medications, jail medical intake, and any behavior captured on 911 audio or body camera video near the time of the offense.
  2. Retain a confidential defense expert to evaluate the client and review the records before anything is disclosed to the State.
  3. File the notice no later than 15 days after arraignment or the written plea of not guilty. The notice must include a statement of particulars describing the insanity the defense expects to prove and the names and addresses of its witnesses, as far as possible.
  4. Prepare the client for the State’s examination. Once the notice is filed, the court must order an evaluation by the State’s mental health expert if the State asks for one.
  5. Try the case with experts and lay witnesses who saw the client’s behavior, and litigate the jury instructions so the jury applies the current statutory test.

If counsel has reasonable grounds to believe the client may be incompetent to proceed, Rule 3.216(c) requires the insanity notice to be filed at the same time as the motion for a competency examination.

What is the difference between competency and insanity?

Competency asks about the person’s mind now; insanity asks about the person’s mind at the moment of the offense. A defendant who cannot understand the charges or help the lawyer is incompetent to proceed, and the case pauses for restoration under chapter 916. Insanity is a defense to the charge itself, decided by the jury or judge at trial. The same person can raise both, and often the competency evaluation is the first record that documents the illness. Our post on competency to proceed in Florida explains that process step by step.

Competency vs. insanity in Florida: competency looks at the mind now, asks whether the person can help the lawyer, and pauses the case for treatment; insanity looks at the time of the act, asks whether the person knew it was wrong, and leads to a verdict, then a commitment decision. The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
QuestionCompetency to proceedInsanity defense
Time examinedThe defendant’s condition now, during the caseThe defendant’s condition at the time of the offense
Legal questionCan the person understand the case and assist counsel?Did the person know what he or she was doing, or that it was wrong?
Who raises itDefense, State, or the court on its ownDefense only, by written notice under Rule 3.216
Result if foundCase pauses for restoration treatmentVerdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, then a commitment decision
Main lawChapter 916, Florida StatutesSection 775.027, Florida Statutes
Competency to proceed compared with the insanity defense in Florida

What happens after a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict in Florida?

The judge decides what happens next. Under Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.217, the verdict must state that it was given by reason of insanity, and if the court finds the person meets the legal criteria, the judge “shall commit the defendant to the Department of Children and Families or shall order outpatient treatment at any other appropriate facility or service, or shall discharge the defendant.”

Commitment turns on present dangerousness. Under section 916.15, Florida Statutes, a person acquitted by reason of insanity may be involuntarily committed if the person “has a mental illness and, because of the illness, is manifestly dangerous to himself or herself or others.” The facility must report to the court no later than 6 months after admission, and a hearing must be held within 30 days after the court learns the person no longer meets the criteria. The statute sets no fixed end date for commitment, so it can last longer than the prison sentence the charge would have carried.

At the North Florida Evaluation and Treatment Center, one of the state’s secure forensic hospitals, the average stay for a person committed as not guilty by reason of insanity is about 24 months, compared with about 4 months for a person committed as incompetent to proceed, according to the Florida Department of Children and Families (figures on the department’s forensic facilities page, checked November 2026). The Forensic Service at Florida State Hospital alone has capacity for 469 people.

Insanity defense in Florida by the numbers: 1% of felony cases raise insanity and 26% of insanity pleas won acquittal (eight-state study, Bulletin of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, 1991); average NGRI stay at the North Florida Evaluation and Treatment Center about 24 months, and Florida State Hospital forensic capacity of 469 (Florida DCF, 2026). The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

Can a jury find someone insane on one count and sane on another?

Yes. In Qosaj v. State, No. 2D18-4109 (Fla. 2d DCA June 10, 2020), a Pinellas County jury heard a defense psychologist testify that the accused was psychotic during an attack on a 74-year-old woman, and a State psychologist testify that he had no mental illness. The jury found him not guilty by reason of insanity of attempted first-degree murder but guilty of aggravated battery on a person 65 or older and four other counts. The Second District affirmed. It held the verdicts were not legally inconsistent and noted the jury may have found him insane during one attack and sane during the other.

For clients in Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco, Qosaj means the defense has to tie the expert opinion to each act and each moment the State charges. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm build that timeline from the 911 call, the first officer’s observations, and the booking records before the experts write their reports.

When is insanity the wrong strategy?

Insanity is often the wrong choice for a lower-level charge, because a commitment with no fixed end date can last far longer than the sentence the client would otherwise face. It is also a poor fit when the records cannot show the illness at the time of the act, or when the client’s own statements show planning or concealment that a jury will read as knowing the act was wrong.

Hillsborough County offers other paths. The 13th Judicial Circuit runs mental health court as one of its problem-solving courts, and I served on the circuit’s Problem-Solving Courts Oversight Committee from 2012 to 2023. Our attorneys often pursue a treatment-based resolution, a negotiated plea built on mental health mitigation, or a downward departure at sentencing, and we raise insanity when the evidence of the client’s state at the time of the act is strong enough to carry the clear and convincing burden.

Why do the first weeks after an arrest matter for an insanity defense?

The best evidence of a person’s mental state at the time of the offense is created in the first hours and days: the 911 call, body camera video, jail medical screening, and the observations of family members. Some of it is overwritten or lost if no one asks for it early. The 15-day notice deadline under Rule 3.216 also runs from arraignment, which is an early stop in the Florida criminal case process, so the defense needs the records and a confidential evaluation underway before then. Our attorneys move to preserve that evidence and gather treatment records as early as the case allows.

Frequently asked questions about the insanity defense in Florida

Is temporary insanity a defense in Florida?

Florida has no separate temporary insanity defense; the same M’Naghten test in section 775.027 applies whether the illness lasted years or one episode. The Brancato Law Firm focuses the expert evaluation on the exact time of the act, which is where a short-lived episode is won or lost.

Can drug-induced psychosis support an insanity defense in Florida?

Usually not, because section 775.051 bars evidence of voluntary intoxication to show insanity, except for a controlled substance taken under the defendant’s own lawful prescription. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm look closely at whether an underlying illness, apart from the drug use, explains the person’s state, and they review the prescription history.

Do I have to meet with the State’s psychologist if I raise insanity?

Yes, if the State asks: once the defense files its notice, Rule 3.216(d) requires the court to order an examination by the State’s mental health expert, and the attorneys for both sides may attend. The Brancato Law Firm prepares each client for that examination and attends when it helps protect the client’s rights, and our guide to expert witnesses in criminal cases explains how those experts are used at trial.

How long is someone committed after a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict in Florida?

There is no fixed term; under section 916.15 the person stays committed while the person has a mental illness and is manifestly dangerous, with a facility report due within 6 months and hearings after that. Our attorneys at The Brancato Law Firm explain that open-ended exposure to every client before an insanity notice is filed, and they compare it with the likely sentence on the charge.

Can criminal charges be dropped because of mental illness in Florida?

Sometimes, though usually through competency, a mental health court or treatment-based resolution, or a negotiated outcome rather than an outright dismissal. The Brancato Law Firm presents treatment records and a plan to the prosecutor early, and our criminal mental health defense team handles these cases in Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties.

Could an AI chatbot’s influence be part of an insanity defense?

Only if the evidence shows a real mental illness that, at the time of the act, kept the person from knowing what he or she was doing or that it was wrong; the chatbot alone would not meet section 775.027. The Brancato Law Firm has written about how an AI insanity defense would be tested in Florida, and the same M’Naghten test would apply.

For more about our defense strategies, visit our Criminal Mental Health Defense page.

The insanity notice is due 15 days after arraignment, so the records and the first evaluation need to start now. Call The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato, at (813) 727-7159, and our attorneys will begin collecting the treatment, jail, and scene records that show your loved one’s condition at the time of the arrest. You can call us at any hour, and our office is two blocks from the courthouse. Our firm has Spanish-speaking staff, and attorney Jean-Luc Adrien speaks Spanish, Haitian Creole, and French.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

What Our Clients Are Saying

Jean-Luc is a Great lawyer to put your trust into

Darrin L.

Jean-luc Adrien es un excelente abogado me ayudó mucho en mi proceso y lo recomiendo. (English: Jean-Luc Adrien is an excellent lawyer. He helped me a lot with my case, and I recommend him.)

Stiven P.

Brancato Law Firm is hands down the BEST Firm in the Tampa Bay area! The move swift and fast with professionalism. I would HIGHLY RECOMMEND them to support you and your judicial needs. Jean-Luc is a GREAT attorney and would request his service if in need!

Anthony J.

One of top criminal defense lawyers, deep experience, very trustworthy. No gimic.

Mahmoud M.

Rocky is incredible! Extremely knowledgeable, excellent communication with updates as the case goes on without you having to reach out to him, and you can tell he truly cares about what he does. Would recommend this law firm to anyone! Would give 10 stars if I could. Thank you so...

Bryton Ennis

Rocky Brancato was able to provide me with legal help that I didn't even imagine was possible. Because of his experience and knowledge he got me life changing results and that is no exaggeration. Rocky has an in depth knowledge of his field, decades of experience, and...

E. M.

Rocky is the best lawyer. He believed in me when no one else did. He fought hard, and did not stop working until he found the evidence we needed to win my case and clear my name. When he took on my case, it had been already ongoing for quite some time, many other lawyers turned...

Molly G.

I highly recommend Rocky! He was professional, knowledgeable, and always available to answer our questions. He worked hard on our case and helped us achieve a great outcome. A special thanks to his assistant as well—he was incredibly friendly, helpful, and treated us like family...

Akrm E.

Mans got me outta jail he legit !!

NFG President Kay

I’m incredibly grateful for the help I received from this law firm. His knowledge and expertise were evident right away, and he handled everything in a timely and professional way. What stood out most to me was the way I was treated—with care, respect, and genuine decency...

Kristen Crotinger

I had an excellent experience working with Rocky Brancato during an extremely stressful and sensitive situation involving false allegations. From the very beginning, Rocky provided clear, sound advice and took the time to truly listen to all of my concerns without ever...

David E

Rocky is a great lawyer. He jumped on my case and provided almost instant results. He communicated well and made sure we understood our options and the next steps. 5 stars!!!

Jasmine

These folks are awesome, they addressed all my concerns and were very professional.

Willem P.

I don’t even know how to start writing this. This man saved me from something I didn’t do. He’s the best.. thank you thank you .

Jonathan S.

Mr. Brancato deserves five stars from day one. He went over and beyond for me. He doesnt just handle small cases I was facing a trafficking fentanyl charge for something that I didnt do and Mr. Brancato got all of my charges dropped. He is a great attorney. He answered any...

Andrea M

I contacted Rocky Brancato at Brancato Law Firm for guidance regarding Florida law and a potential travel matter. He was straightforward, candid, and extremely professional in his advice. I truly appreciated his honesty and clear explanation of the legal landscape. I would highly...

Kevin Marcus

Rocky Brancato is diligent, trustworthy, with an extraordinary human and professional quality, a gift for people and integrity. All these virtues make him an invaluable attorney. Rocky Brancato has been with our family since day one of this stressful, unfair, and overwhelming...

Lein L.

ROCKY IS GREAT HE DID IT TWICE FOR MY FIANCÉ

Mantha W.

I would recommend Mr. Brancato to absolutely anybody. I have been fighting this specific case for about 4 years now and he was able to set time aside to accommodate and was able to get the charges dismissed in less than a WEEK. I can’t thank him enough, and anybody in the Tampa...

Kellz C.

The rare lawyer with a heart Mr. Brancato not only proved his legal acumen, but he did so with genuine empathy and caring. I felt he was personally invested in my success, and acted above and beyond my expectations. He kept me informed all steps of the process, and was upfront...

I.

Mark my words, THIS IS THE BEST LAWYER I’ve ever had the chance to meet and it’s been a pleasure and a major blessing to have him, i had a very difficult case but in less then 5 business day he took the weight of a planet off my shoulders . He goes above and beyond and then did...

Yian V.

Great attorney ! Handled client with care and answered all concerns! Thank you so much !!! A Hard worker is this guy! Thank You for all you did for my fiancé!

Kailyn B.

Rocky Brancato was knowledgeable, responsive, and very professional throughout the entire process. I highly recommend this law firm.

Noel F.

It’s no surprise that this practice has a perfect five-star rating – and they deserve it. I live in Miami, but called Rocky after doing a Google search about my issue. Not only did he get right to the point and answer my questions, he didn’t even charge me. And - I was talking on...

Rob S.

Rocky was the best lawyer i have recieved! He always kept me updated and talked me through everything i couldnt have asked for a better lawyer! Hoping i never have to use him again but he is my go to!! Thank yu rocky it was a pleasure

Lucciano Carmelo

I had a consultation with Rocky and it was exactly what I needed. He listened carefully, gave clear, honest advice, and outlined a smart path forward. Thanks to his guidance and expertise, I now know exactly how to handle the situation. I highly recommend Rocky!

C. Cole

I felt very lucky to be represented by brancato law firm Never had any issues with communication or help with resources and made the whole process easier to navigate Very greatfull he helped me reach the best outcome

Logan Traun

Atty Rocky Brancato is an excellent attorney. He genuinely cares about his clients. You would not find anyone else as compassionate and talented as he is as a lawyer. I would 100% recommend him.

Ana R.

Rocky is an excellent attorney! He demonstrates his passion, dedication and strong work ethic for every single case he accepts. He always go that extra mile to gain his clients trust and satisfaction. Highly recommended!

Bryan N.

Great Lawyer

Joe C.

Thank you for everything!

Kali L.

Attorney Brancato was phenomenal. If I could give him more than 5 stars I would. Very professional, polite, and just overall AMAZING. The only one that actually took the time to help me with a specific case I had for the past few years. I can’t begin to thank him enough.

Keelie

Our family had a great experience with Attorney Rocky Brancato. I wish I could give him more than five stars!

Lola J.

Very thorough and willing to help. I’m glad I chose to contact this office. I always worry about being given the run around but not here I was even given a call back to be sure that he didn’t miss anything. Thanks A+

Mark D.

Rocky went out of his way to help me. he is a very good man

David N.

Attorney Rocky Brancato of the Brancato Law Firm, P.A. Delivered on short notice in our family’s time of need. Fast response, humble and affordable.

Jose V.

Visit Us

Tampa Office
620 E Twiggs St Suite #205

Tampa, FL 33602

Located minutes from the Hillsborough County Courthouse.
Map Shield Image

Contact Us Now

Free Legal Consultation (813) 727-7159

Rocky Brancato in his office in Tampa

Meet Rocky Brancato

For over 25 years, Rocky Brancato has been a prominent force in Tampa Bay’s legal arena. Rocky rose to second-in-command at Tampa Bay’s largest defense firm before launching Brancato Law Firm, P.A. As a former specialized major crimes attorney for serious offenses like...