Florida Court Reverses Murder Conviction

Defense Attorney’s Failures Made Trial “Fundamentally Unfair”

De Santus v. State, No. 4D2023-2235 (Fla. 4th DCA Oct. 15, 2025)

When Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal reversed a murder conviction in De Santus v. State, it exposed a painful truth: even a serious homicide case can collapse when the defense lawyer isn’t prepared. The judges ruled that the attorney’s mistakes made the entire trial fundamentally unfair.

This ruling should make anyone accused of murder stop and ask: how do I choose a homicide attorney in Florida? How do I know my lawyer is truly a homicide attorney—and not just claiming to be one?

What the Defense Attorney Failed to Do

A Case Built on Words, Not Evidence

The Broward County shooting had no DNA, fingerprints, or video evidence. The State relied entirely on one witness. Before trial, that witness admitted to lying—she told a defense investigator that another man, “Gangsta Baby,” had the gun.

Yet the defense attorney never used that prior statement to challenge her credibility. The jury never learned she had recanted. They also never heard that she allegedly tried to extort money from the defendant’s family. Both details could have changed the outcome.

Later, a new witness came forward and testified that the shooter was a light-skinned man in a red jacket—not De Santus. The appellate court concluded the trial had been irreparably tainted by counsel’s failures.

Anyone Can Call Themselves a “Homicide Attorney”

Questions to Ask Before Hiring

Before you trust your future to anyone claiming to be a homicide attorney, ask these questions directly:

1. How many homicide trials have you personally handled from start to verdict?
2. Have you ever obtained a not-guilty verdict in a homicide case?
3. Who will actually stand beside me in court—you, or an associate?
4. What is your record when the State’s evidence seems overwhelming?
5. Are you certified under Florida Supreme Court standards to handle death penalty cases?

If your lawyer hesitates on any of these questions, keep searching.

Homicide Results That Demonstrate Preparation

At The Brancato Law Firm, I don’t just claim experience—I prove it in court:

Roommate Homicide — Not Guilty

A man charged with killing his roommate was acquitted after my direct examination showed the shooting was in self-defense. The jury returned a swift not-guilty verdict.

Grandmother Homicide — Charge Reduced

A grandmother initially charged with murder and aggravated child abuse avoided a life sentence after evidence showed the child’s injuries resulted from CPR efforts. The charge was reduced to child neglect with probation.

Second-Degree Murder — Reduced to Manslaughter

A jury found that my client’s shooting of his friend, while not exactly self-defense, was not “depraved mind” second-degree murder—resulting in a significantly reduced sentence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why was the De Santus conviction reversed?

The Fourth DCA found that defense counsel’s combined errors—failing to use key impeachment evidence and failing to advise the client about testifying—violated the right to a fair trial. The court concluded these weren’t minor mistakes but fundamental failures that tainted the entire proceeding.

What is impeachment evidence?

Impeachment evidence challenges a witness’s credibility. In De Santus, the key witness had previously told a defense investigator that someone else—”Gangsta Baby”—had the gun. That prior inconsistent statement could have undermined her entire testimony, but the attorney never used it.

How do I verify an attorney’s homicide experience?

Ask directly: how many homicide trials have you handled to verdict? Request specific case outcomes. Check whether they’re death-penalty qualified under Florida Rule 3.112. If they hesitate or deflect, that tells you something.

Will the attorney I hire actually handle my case?

Ask before hiring. Some firms advertise experienced partners but assign cases to junior associates. At The Brancato Law Firm, every homicide case is handled personally—not by junior staff.

Facing Homicide Charges in Tampa Bay?

The De Santus case demonstrates what happens when preparation fails. A homicide trial demands experience, judgment, and attention to every detail. Anything less risks a lifetime behind bars.

I’m Tampa Attorney Rocky Brancato. For more than 25 years, I have defended serious felony and homicide cases throughout Tampa Bay. As a former member of major-crimes and sex-crimes units in Tampa’s largest criminal defense office, I have the perspective that only decades in the courtroom can bring. Check out our Tampa Homicide Attorney Page.

I keep my caseload low so every client receives the preparation their case demands. If I’m too busy or it’s not the right fit, I’ll tell you—I won’t take a case I can’t handle properly.

Don’t assume every “homicide attorney” has the experience your life demands. Look behind the veil—before it’s too late.

Call (813) 727-7159 for a Confidential Consultation

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602

Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties