I’m Rocky Brancato, founder of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., a Tampa criminal defense firm. I’ve taken more than 150 jury trials to verdict over 25 years in Hillsborough County courtrooms, and assault cases are where our attorneys most often see overcharging — road-rage arguments, bar disputes, and neighbor feuds written up as felonies because someone mentioned a weapon.

How Does Florida Define Assault?

Most people think assault means hitting someone. In Florida, hitting is battery. Assault is the threat — and section 784.011, Florida Statutes requires the State to prove three things, each beyond a reasonable doubt:

1. An intentional, unlawful threat — by word or act — to do violence to another person;
2. An apparent ability to carry the threat out at that moment; and
3. An act creating a well-founded fear in the other person that the violence is imminent.

Simple assault is a second-degree misdemeanor — up to 60 days in jail and a $500 fine. But look at how much work those elements do. A threat to do something later (“wait until next week”) is not imminent. An angry outburst with no ability to follow through fails the second element. And the alleged victim’s fear must be well-founded — objectively reasonable, not just claimed. Our attorneys win these cases element by element.

What Is the Difference Between Assault and Battery?

Assault is the threat; battery is the touch. Battery under section 784.03 requires an actual, intentional touching or striking against the person’s will — even a shove or a grabbed wrist qualifies. The two are separate crimes that often travel together in one arrest, but each has to be proven on its own elements. The distinction matters at negotiation time, because an assault count built on words and fear is usually the weaker count — and it is often the one that falls first.

What Is Aggravated Assault in Florida?

Aggravated assault under section 784.021, Florida Statutes is a simple assault plus one of two aggravators: it was committed with a deadly weapon without intent to kill, or with intent to commit a felony. Either version is a third-degree felony — up to 5 years in prison and a $5,000 fine.

That jump — from a 60-day misdemeanor to a 5-year felony — usually turns on a single disputed fact: whether an object was a “deadly weapon.” Which is why that question deserves its own section.

What Counts as a Deadly Weapon in Florida?

Only one object is a deadly weapon as a matter of law: a firearm. Everything else depends on how it was used — and that makes it a jury question the defense can fight. The test Florida courts apply: an instrument is a deadly weapon if it is likely to cause death or great bodily harm when used in the ordinary manner contemplated by its design, or if it was actually used or threatened to be used in a way likely to produce death or great bodily harm. A knife — despite what most people assume — is not necessarily a deadly weapon; a baseball bat, a bottle, even a car can be one or not, depending entirely on the facts.

The Third District’s decision in Verela v. State, No. 3D2024-0402 (Fla. 3d DCA Mar. 5, 2025) shows how much precision matters in weapon cases. Verela was charged with attempted murder “by stabbing,” and a jury convicted him of the lesser offense of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon. The appellate court threw that conviction out — because the charging document never actually alleged that he used a deadly weapon, and a court cannot instruct a jury on an offense whose elements the State never charged. The conviction was reduced to simple battery. The lesson for anyone facing a weapon allegation: these cases are won on details — what was charged, what was proven, and whether the object in question legally qualifies at all.

Does 10-20-Life Apply to Aggravated Assault?

No — and this is one of the most persistent myths in Florida criminal law.

Check the current list yourself: the enumerated felonies in section 775.087(2), Florida Statutes — the 10-20-Life statute — include aggravated battery, robbery, burglary, and others, but not aggravated assault. The Legislature removed it in 2016 after years of cases in which people who displayed a gun in self-defense situations faced decades in prison. The weapon-reclassification rule in section 775.087(1) does not apply either when the weapon is what makes the crime aggravated assault in the first place, because reclassification is barred where use of a weapon is an essential element of the charge. None of this makes a firearm allegation minor — it changes plea dynamics, scoresheet points, and how the State charges — but the automatic 10- and 20-year minimums people fear do not attach to aggravated assault. If a prosecutor’s offer assumes otherwise, our attorneys make the correction in writing.

What Are the Enhanced Penalties for Assault on Protected Victims?

September 2026 update: When the alleged victim is 60 or older, an assault or battery is frequently charged instead as abuse of an elderly person under section 825.102, which is a felony at every level. The State must then prove that an infirmity of aging impaired the person, not just the person’s age. Our rewritten guide, Is Elder Abuse a Felony in Florida, and What Does the State Have to Prove?, covers the Second District’s Watson v. State decision and the penalty tiers.

Florida reclassifies assault crimes upward when the alleged victim belongs to a protected class engaged in official duties. Under section 784.07, an assault on a law enforcement officer, firefighter, or emergency medical provider performing lawful duties moves up one level — simple assault becomes a first-degree misdemeanor, and aggravated assault becomes a second-degree felony carrying a 3-year mandatory minimum when the victim is a law enforcement officer. Similar reclassifications protect persons 65 or older under section 784.08. Two defense notes: the State must prove the defendant knew the victim’s status, and for officers, that the officer was engaged in the lawful performance of duties — both real, litigable issues.

Can Words Alone Be Assault in Florida?

Almost never. The statute requires a threat coupled with an apparent ability to carry it out and an act creating well-founded fear of imminent violence. Angry words on a phone call cannot put anyone in imminent fear; a threat about next week is not imminent; and a threat with no present ability to act on it fails on its face. Where words become assault is when they arrive with conduct — advancing on someone, raising a fist, reaching for a waistband. In our firm’s experience, prosecutors routinely file assault charges on facts that are really just an ugly argument, and the imminence element is where those cases collapse.

How Do We Defend Assault and Aggravated Assault Charges?

We put the State to its proof on the element it most takes for granted. Was the fear well-founded and the threat truly imminent, or was this a conditional, future, or empty statement? Did our client have the apparent ability to do violence at that moment? Was the object genuinely a deadly weapon under the design-or-use test, or is the felony built on a jury assumption we can challenge? Was this self-defense — Florida law justifies threatening force to meet force, and our attorneys litigate stand-your-ground immunity where the facts support it? And who is actually telling the truth — assault charges arise from two-sided confrontations, and the “victim” is often the person who escalated first. Cross-examination, witness statements, and video decide these cases, and we get to that evidence early.

Can Assault Charges Be Dropped in Florida?

Yes, but not by the alleged victim — only the State Attorney decides whether to prosecute, and a recanting or reluctant victim does not automatically end the case. What actually gets assault charges dropped or reduced: early defense contact with the prosecutor before the formal charging decision, evidence that the threat was conditional or the fear unfounded, self-defense facts, and the weakness of one-witness cases. That pre-file window — after arrest, before the information is filed — is the single highest-leverage period in a misdemeanor or third-degree felony case, and it is why calling a lawyer in the first days matters more than anything else you do.

What Should You Do If You Are Charged with Assault?

Say nothing about the incident to anyone but your lawyer, and start preserving your side immediately. Assault cases are credibility contests: texts, social media messages, surveillance video, and witnesses who saw who approached whom disappear or go stale within weeks. Do not contact the alleged victim — in domestic-violence-flagged cases that contact can violate a no-contact order and become a new charge. Write down your account while it is fresh, list every witness, and bring all of it to counsel before your arraignment. Our attorneys use that window to work the charging decision, not just the court date.

Frequently Asked Questions About Assault in Florida

Is assault a felony or a misdemeanor in Florida?

Simple assault is a second-degree misdemeanor punishable by up to 60 days in jail. Aggravated assault — with a deadly weapon or intent to commit a felony — is a third-degree felony punishable by up to 5 years. The gap between those two outcomes usually rides on one disputed fact, which is why our attorneys treat every “weapon” allegation as the case’s central battle.

Can I be charged with assault if I never touched anyone?

Yes — assault in Florida is the threat, not the touch. But the State must prove an intentional threat, apparent ability, and an act creating well-founded fear of imminent violence. If any element is missing — the threat was conditional, the fear unreasonable, the ability absent — the charge fails.

Is a knife automatically a deadly weapon?

No. Under Florida law only a firearm is a deadly weapon as a matter of law; a knife’s status depends on how it was used or threatened to be used, and that is a question of fact. In Verela v. State (Fla. 3d DCA 2025), even a conviction in a stabbing case was reversed over how the weapon allegation was charged. Our firm scrutinizes both the object and the paperwork.

Does pulling a gun mean a mandatory 10 years?

Not for aggravated assault — the Legislature removed aggravated assault from the 10-20-Life statute in 2016, so the automatic 10- and 20-year firearm minimums do not apply to that charge. Firearm facts still raise the stakes in other ways, and related charges can carry their own minimums, so have counsel map the actual exposure rather than assuming the worst.

What happens if the alleged victim doesn’t want to press charges?

The State Attorney, not the victim, controls the prosecution — the case does not automatically go away. But a reluctant victim changes the practical strength of the case, and early defense advocacy can turn that into a declination or reduction. The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. works these cases in the pre-file window, when the charging decision is still being made.

What is the penalty for aggravated assault on a police officer?

It is reclassified to a second-degree felony — up to 15 years — with a 3-year mandatory minimum under section 784.07. The State must prove you knew the person was an officer and that the officer was lawfully performing official duties; both are contested issues our attorneys litigate. Call The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. at (813) 727-7159 for a free, confidential case review.

For more about our defense strategies, visit our Hillsborough County Criminal Defense Attorney page.

Related reading: What Is Robbery in Florida? · What Are the Gun Crime Laws in Florida? · What Is Disorderly Conduct in Florida? · What to Do After Being Arrested in Tampa, Florida · How Does a Bond Hearing Work in Tampa, Florida?

An Argument Became a Criminal Case — Now Make It a Fair Fight

If you have been arrested for assault or aggravated assault in Hillsborough, Pinellas, or Pasco County, the most important decisions in your case are being made in the next few weeks — by a prosecutor who has only heard one side. Call the attorneys of The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. — founded by Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato — at (813) 727-7159 before your arraignment. The charging decision is still open; make sure your side of the story reaches it.

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.
620 E. Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602
(813) 727-7159
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. is a Tampa-based criminal defense practice. We are not affiliated with any other Brancato-named law firms.

At The Brancato Law Firm, we defend serious cases across Tampa Bay, and our founder has tried more than 150 jury trials to verdict, including cases won on self-defense. We have used Florida’s self-defense law to get charges dismissed before trial. This guide explains how a self-defense claim actually works in Florida: what you have to prove, how Stand Your Ground and the Castle Doctrine change the math, what a pretrial immunity hearing is, and what your early decisions (especially whether to talk to police) do to the rest of the case. We will not tell you that everything will be fine, because that depends on facts we cannot see. What we can do is explain the machine you are now inside of, so you understand the decisions in front of you.

What does “claiming self-defense” mean in Florida?

In Florida, self-defense is called the justifiable use of force, and it lives in Chapter 776, Florida Statutes. That chapter sets the rules for when force is legally allowed and when it is not.

This matters because “self-defense” in everyday speech is a moral statement: I did the right thing. In a courtroom it is a technical defense. The law does not ask whether you are a good person who was put in a terrible position. It asks whether your conduct fits the specific conditions the statute lays out. When those conditions are met, the force was justified and you are not guilty of a crime. When the prosecution can knock out even one of them, the claim weakens fast.

Florida’s framework did not invent self-defense. It expanded the older common-law right by removing the duty to retreat, adding strong presumptions inside the home, and creating immunity from prosecution. Those three additions are why Florida is one of the most defendant-favorable self-defense states in the country. But they are conditions, not guarantees. Knowing exactly what they require is the difference between a claim that holds and one that collapses under cross-examination.

The four things a self-defense claim has to prove

To raise self-defense successfully, the facts generally have to support four elements. Think of these as the legs of a table. Remove one and the whole thing falls.

A few points worth understanding, because they come up constantly:

• The danger does not have to be real, only reasonably perceived. Florida law allows a person to act in self-defense based on a threat that turns out to be a mistake, as long as the appearance of danger was real enough that a reasonable person would have believed it. If someone pulls what looks like a gun and it later turns out to be a phone, that does not automatically destroy the claim.
  
• “Reasonable” is judged from your position, not with hindsight. The standard asks what a reasonable and prudent person, in the same circumstances and knowing what you knew at that instant, would have done. Not what looks reasonable on a calm afternoon months later with all the facts laid out.
  
• Proportionality is where good claims go to die. The most common way a self-defense case falls apart is force that the jury sees as too much: continuing to strike after the other person is down, or answering a shove with a gun. Matching the response to the threat is everything.
  

Non-deadly force vs. deadly force in Florida (and the warning-shot trap)

Florida treats non-deadly and deadly force as two different things with two different triggers, both set out in the state’s use-of-force statute. Getting this distinction wrong is one of the most dangerous mistakes a defender can make, often without realizing it.

Here is the trap that catches people who believe they were being careful. Under Florida law, pointing or displaying a firearm is generally treated as non-deadly force, but firing it is deadly force as a matter of law, even a warning shot fired into the air or the ground (Hosnedl v. State). People often think a warning shot is the restrained, de-escalating choice. Legally, the moment the gun goes off, you have used deadly force, and you now have to justify it as if you had aimed at the person. That single fact has turned what felt like a measured response into a far more serious charge for many defenders, which is why firearm-related charges and self-defense so often have to be worked together.

What is “Stand Your Ground” and how does it remove the “you could have walked away” argument?

Stand Your Ground means you have no legal duty to retreat before defending yourself, as long as you are somewhere you have a right to be and are not committing a crime. Before 2005, Florida followed the common-law “duty to retreat,” which generally required a person to back away if they safely could before using deadly force in public. The 2005 law abolished that duty anywhere a person is lawfully present.

In practical terms, this takes a powerful weapon away from the prosecution. Without Stand Your Ground, a prosecutor can stand in front of a jury and ask, “Why didn’t you just leave? You could have walked away.” Under Florida law, that argument is off the table. The jury is not allowed to convict you on the theory that you should have retreated. You were entitled to stand your ground.

Florida is one of the majority of states that have adopted some form of Stand Your Ground, whether by statute or through court decisions. Only a small group of states, eleven in total, still impose a duty to retreat in public, and even those drop the requirement inside your own home.

The strategic takeaway: in Florida, the fight is almost always about whether your belief and your level of force were reasonable, not about whether you had an escape route you ignored.

How does the Castle Doctrine protect you at home or in your vehicle?

The Castle Doctrine is the strongest version of self-defense Florida offers, and it applies to your home and your occupied vehicle. Under Florida’s home-protection statute, if someone unlawfully and forcibly enters your dwelling or occupied vehicle, the law presumes you held a reasonable fear of imminent death or great bodily harm. Florida is one of the few states that builds in this presumption of fear, rather than making you prove it from scratch.

That presumption is the whole game. Normally you have to prove your fear was reasonable. With the Castle Doctrine, the law starts by assuming it was, and the prosecution has to rebut that assumption. A documented forcible entry, such as a kicked-in door or a smashed window, dramatically strengthens the claim, because it triggers the presumption in your favor and forces the State onto the back foot.

“Dwelling” is defined broadly. It covers any building or conveyance with a roof designed for people to sleep in, temporary or permanent, including a tent. The presumption does not apply in a few situations, including when the person you used force against had a legal right to be there (for example, a co-owner or someone on the lease, absent a domestic violence injunction), when you were engaged in criminal activity, or when the person entering was a law enforcement officer performing official duties.

What is a Stand Your Ground immunity hearing?

This is the part most people have never heard of, and it can change everything. In Florida, self-defense is not only a defense you raise at trial. It is also grounds for immunity from prosecution, decided at a separate hearing before trial.

Section 776.032 grants true immunity, not just a defense. The statute says a person who used justified force is immune from criminal prosecution, and it defines “criminal prosecution” to include being arrested, detained, charged, and prosecuted. Your attorney raises this by filing a pretrial motion to dismiss. The judge then holds an evidentiary hearing and decides whether the immunity applies.

If the judge grants immunity, the case is over. It ends before a jury is ever seated. That is why a self-defense case in Florida often has two separate shots at winning, and the immunity hearing is the earlier one. These hearings carry the most weight in the most serious cases, including homicide cases where a dismissal means avoiding a trial that could otherwise put a person’s life on the line.

The 2017 burden shift that made Florida unique

For years, the defendant carried the burden at the immunity hearing. That changed in 2017. The Legislature amended the statute so that once the defendant makes a prima facie claim of self-defense (essentially, a basic showing that the defense applies), the burden shifts to the State to overcome immunity by clear and convincing evidence. Florida is the only state to put the burden on the prosecution at this stage.

Read those two standards together and you can see why Florida is so favorable to defenders. At the hearing, the State has to clear a high bar to keep the case alive. At trial, it has to clear an even higher one. At no point does the law make you prove you are innocent. The State has to prove you were not justified.

Why the immunity hearing is not a free swing

Here is the catch, and it is a real one. To make your case at the immunity hearing, you may have to testify, and that testimony can be used against you later at trial.

So the immunity hearing is not a costless first attempt. If you take the stand at the hearing and the judge denies immunity, the prosecution now has your sworn account, locked in, to pick apart in front of the jury. Every word becomes material for cross-examination. A skilled prosecutor will compare your hearing testimony against every other piece of evidence, looking for any inconsistency.

This is exactly the kind of decision that separates experienced self-defense counsel from a lawyer who treats the immunity hearing as an obvious move. Sometimes leading with the hearing is clearly right, especially when the Castle Doctrine presumption applies or when you are the only surviving witness and the State may not be able to meet its burden. Sometimes the smarter play is to hold your testimony and fight at trial, where the State faces the higher standard. There is no universal answer. It depends on the specific facts, the evidence the State holds, and what your testimony exposes.

If you lose the immunity hearing, is the case over?

No. Losing immunity is not losing the case. This is one of the most important things for a frightened defendant to understand.

If the judge denies immunity, self-defense is still a full defense at trial. You get to make the entire argument again to a jury, and at trial the State faces the tougher standard: it must disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt. Florida courts have made clear that once any evidence of self-defense is presented, the burden is on the State to disprove it. That is why people describe Florida self-defense cases as having “two bites at the apple.”

A denial at the immunity hearing is a hard day, but the fight continues at trial under rules that still favor you.

There is also a procedural option to challenge a denial of immunity before trial through an appellate filing, which an experienced attorney will evaluate depending on the situation.

When does a self-defense claim collapse?

Florida’s law is generous, but it has hard limits. The claim is unavailable, or badly weakened, in these situations:

• You were the initial aggressor. If you started the fight, you generally cannot claim self-defense, unless you genuinely withdrew, clearly communicated that you were withdrawing, and the other person kept coming. Florida’s aggressor rule means provoking a confrontation and then using force is the fastest way to lose the defense.
  
• You were committing another crime. Engaging in criminal activity strips away the “no duty to retreat” protection and can disqualify the claim entirely. The benefit of Stand Your Ground is reserved for people who were lawfully present and law-abiding at the time.
  
• You used force against a known law enforcement officer. Under the statute on resisting arrest, you are not justified in using force to resist an arrest by an officer who is acting in good faith and is known, or reasonably appears, to be an officer. Immunity does not apply against an identified officer performing official duties.
  
• You used deadly force to protect property alone. Florida does not allow deadly force purely to defend property. Deadly force in a property situation is only justified if you were preventing an imminent forcible felony, not simply stopping a theft or trespass.
  

The reason these matters require careful legal analysis is that prosecutors look hard for any of these facts. A claim that looks clean to the person who lived it can have a disqualifier buried in it that only surfaces under scrutiny. Identifying that early, and addressing it, is core defense work.

What should you do in the first 24 hours after a self-defense incident?

The early hours shape the entire case. What you do now, while the adrenaline is still up, often matters more than anything that happens months later in a courtroom. Three things matter most:

1. Stay silent and ask for a lawyer. This is the hardest advice to follow and the most important. When you believe you did nothing wrong, the instinct is to explain, to make the officers understand. Resist it. Even a truthful, innocent explanation can be reframed by a prosecutor into something that sounds like an admission. You have the right to remain silent and the right to counsel. Use both. Say you want a lawyer, and then stop talking.
   
2. Preserve evidence before it disappears. Surveillance footage gets overwritten. Witnesses leave and their memories fade. Injuries heal. Early counsel can move quickly to secure video, lock down witness statements, and document physical evidence and medical records while they still exist. In self-defense cases, the evidence that proves your fear was reasonable is often the first to vanish.
   
3. Get experienced criminal defense counsel involved immediately. Self-defense cases are fact-intensive and procedure-heavy. The decisions made in the first days, including whether to pursue an immunity hearing and how to protect your testimony, set the trajectory of everything that follows.
   

If you already gave a statement to police before reading this, do not panic, and do not assume the case is lost. It complicates things, but experienced counsel deals with this situation regularly. The most useful thing you can do now is stop talking to anyone except your attorney.

What does experienced counsel change in a self-defense case?

A self-defense claim is won or lost on judgment calls that a first-time defendant has no way to evaluate alone. Whether to testify at the immunity hearing. Whether the Castle Doctrine presumption applies to your facts. Whether a disqualifier is lurking in the timeline. How to preserve the evidence that makes your fear look reasonable to a jury. Whether to lead with the pretrial motion or hold your fire for trial.

These are not abstract questions. They are the actual machinery of the case, and they get decided in the first weeks. At The Brancato Law Firm, our work on self-defense and other violent crime cases draws on attorney Rocky Brancato’s background as a former Chief Operations Officer of the Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office, where he helped lead the largest criminal defense operation in the Tampa Bay region. That system-level knowledge informs how we evaluate self-defense cases: where the State’s proof tends to be weak, how prosecutors build around a self-defense claim, and which early moves protect a client’s position. We pursue Stand Your Ground immunity hearings where the facts support it, and we have used these motions to get serious charges dismissed before trial. Each case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

A public defender can do excellent work, and for someone who cannot afford private counsel, that is the right path. But public defender offices carry heavy caseloads. A self-defense case demands the time to investigate fast, prepare the immunity motion carefully, and make the strategic call on testimony with full attention. That bandwidth is what serious self-defense preparation requires.

Frequently asked questions about claiming self-defense in Florida

These are the questions we hear most often from people in this situation. You can find answers to more general questions on our Tampa criminal law FAQ page.

Does Florida law require me to retreat before defending myself?

No. Under Florida’s Stand Your Ground law, you have no duty to retreat as long as you are somewhere you have a legal right to be and are not committing a crime. The prosecution cannot argue to a jury that you should have walked away.

Is a warning shot considered self-defense in Florida?

Firing a warning shot is treated as deadly force under Florida law, even if you aimed away from the person. That means you have to justify it under the deadly-force standard: a reasonable belief that force was necessary to prevent imminent death, great bodily harm, or a forcible felony. Many people assume a warning shot is the safe, restrained choice, but legally it is not treated that way.

Can self-defense get my charges dismissed before trial?

Yes. Florida allows a pretrial Stand Your Ground immunity hearing where a judge can dismiss the case before it ever reaches a jury. Since 2017, once you make a basic showing of self-defense, the State must overcome immunity by clear and convincing evidence to keep the case alive.

What happens if I already talked to the police?

A prior statement makes the case more complicated, but it does not automatically end your self-defense claim. The most important step now is to stop talking to anyone but your attorney and let experienced counsel manage all further communication with law enforcement.

Does claiming self-defense mean I have to prove I’m innocent?

No. At trial, the State must disprove your self-defense claim beyond a reasonable doubt. At the pretrial immunity hearing, the State must overcome immunity by clear and convincing evidence once you make a prima facie showing. The burden does not rest on you to prove your innocence.

Talk to a Tampa criminal defense attorney about your self-defense case

If you used force to protect yourself and you are now under arrest or under investigation, the early decisions matter most, and they are being made right now. The Brancato Law Firm defends self-defense and serious felony cases throughout Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties. To talk through your situation in a free and confidential consultation, call (813) 727-7159 or reach out through our contact page. We will give you a straight answer about where you stand and what comes next.

This article is general legal information, not legal advice. Self-defense outcomes are highly fact-specific and depend on how police, prosecutors, judges, and juries interpret the evidence in a particular case.

The Florida Fourth District Court of Appeal recently granted Stand Your Ground immunity to a Palm Beach defendant charged with second-degree murder. In Spencer v. State (4D2025-0023), the court ruled that prosecutors failed to disprove self-defense by clear and convincing evidence.

This case demonstrates why Stand Your Ground immunity matters for anyone facing violent crime charges in Florida. Moreover, it illustrates how the burden of proof works in self-defense cases—and why experienced legal representation is essential. I am Tampa Criminal Defense Attorney Rocky Brancato. For over 25 years, I have provide top level criminal defense services to the citizens of Tampa Bay. My firm, the Brancato Law Firm, P.A., can help change the narrative if you used self defense and stood your ground!

Case Background: Palm Beach Stand Your Ground Claim

Ivin Spencer was charged with second-degree murder after a deadly confrontation in a Palm Beach parking lot. Although Spencer admitted to the shooting, he argued that Florida’s Stand Your Ground law applied to his case.

The Victim’s History

The evidence showed that the victim, Brandon Bell, had a history of making threats and was known to carry a gun. Consequently, Spencer had reason to believe that any confrontation with Bell could turn deadly.

The Confrontation

On the day of the shooting, Bell aggressively advanced toward Spencer while yelling threats. Spencer, who had health limitations that put him at a physical disadvantage, feared for his safety. As a result, he fired a single shot.

After the Shooting

Immediately after the incident, Spencer called 911 and cooperated fully with police. This behavior is consistent with someone acting in self-defense rather than with criminal intent.

Why the Court Granted Stand Your Ground Immunity

The appellate court ruled that prosecutors failed to meet their burden of proof. Specifically, the State could not prove by clear and convincing evidence that Spencer’s use of force was unjustified.

Together, these facts supported the conclusion that a reasonable person in Spencer’s position would believe deadly force was necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm.

Lessons from This Florida Self-Defense Ruling

Stand Your Ground Can Dismiss Charges Before Trial

Unlike an acquittal at trial, Stand Your Ground immunity dismisses charges entirely. As a result, the defendant avoids the risk, expense, and uncertainty of a jury trial. This makes pursuing immunity a critical strategy in appropriate cases.

The State Carries a Heavy Burden

Once a defendant raises Stand Your Ground, prosecutors must disprove self-defense by clear and convincing evidence. This is a higher standard than preponderance of the evidence, though lower than beyond a reasonable doubt. Nevertheless, it places significant pressure on the State.

Context Shapes Legal Outcomes

Prior threats, the victim’s reputation, physical disparities, and circumstances at the scene all matter. Therefore, thorough investigation and presentation of context is essential to a successful Stand Your Ground claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Stand Your Ground immunity in Florida?

Stand Your Ground immunity allows a defendant to have criminal charges dismissed before trial if they can show they used force in lawful self-defense. Under Florida law, a person has no duty to retreat if they are in a place where they have a right to be.

Who has the burden of proof in a Stand Your Ground hearing?

Once the defendant raises Stand Your Ground, the burden shifts to the prosecution. The State must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant’s use of force was not justified. If prosecutors cannot meet this burden, the court must grant immunity.

Can Stand Your Ground apply to murder charges?

Yes, absolutely. Stand Your Ground immunity can apply to any charge where self-defense is raised, including first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter. The Spencer case demonstrates that even second-degree murder charges can be dismissed through Stand Your Ground.

What evidence helps a Stand Your Ground claim?

Helpful evidence includes prior threats from the victim, the victim’s violent reputation, physical disparity between the parties, witness testimony about the confrontation, and the defendant’s post-incident conduct such as calling 911 and cooperating with police.

Is Stand Your Ground the same as self-defense?

Stand Your Ground is a specific type of self-defense claim under Florida law. The key difference is that Stand Your Ground eliminates the duty to retreat. In other words, you do not have to try to escape before using force if you are lawfully present at the location.

How do I pursue Stand Your Ground immunity?

Your attorney files a motion for Stand Your Ground immunity, and the court holds a hearing. At that hearing, the prosecution must prove that your use of force was not justified. If they fail, the charges are dismissed. This process requires experienced legal representation.

More on Self-Defense

• Tampa Attorney for Self-Defense
• Tampa PTSD and Self-Defense
• Tampa Criminal Mental Health Attorney
• Tampa Gun Crime Attorney
• Tampa Violent Crime Attorney
• Tampa Murder Attorney

Protect Your Rights with a Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer

If you face violent crime charges where self-defense may apply, you need an attorney who understands how to argue for Stand Your Ground immunity in Florida. At The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., attorney Rocky Brancato has more than 25 years of experience defending homicide, sex crimes, and major felonies throughout Tampa Bay.

Moreover, Attorney Brancato proactively pursues Stand Your Ground immunity hearings for eligible cases. Do not wait until trial to raise self-defense—the right strategy can dismiss charges entirely.

Call (813) 727-7159 for a Confidential Consultation

The Brancato Law Firm, P.A.

620 E Twiggs Street, Suite 205, Tampa, FL 33602

Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco Counties