Murder Conviction Reversed When Police Ignored Miranda Rights

A Florida appeals court recently overturned a murder conviction because police ignored the suspect’s Miranda rights when he made a clear request for a lawyer. The First District Court of Appeal’s decision in Snowden v. State, No. 1D2023-1998 (Fla. 1st DCA July 2, 2025), highlights a core constitutional protection—your right to legal counsel.

Tampa Bay Case Shows Importance of Asking for a Lawyer Clearly

Daquavion Snowden was charged with first-degree murder after a deadly shooting in Escambia County. After his arrest, police placed him in an interview room. He was shirtless, in chains, and under the influence of drugs. Officers told him they would be back soon.

While waiting, Snowden vomited. As he was being moved so the room could be cleaned, he asked, “Is there any way I can talk to my lawyer or anything?” Police didn’t stop to clarify or act on the request. Instead, they resumed the interview an hour later.

Three Times Snowden Asked for a Lawyer—and Police Kept Talking

Snowden didn’t just ask once. He asked for a lawyer three separate times. His second request came during questioning: “That’s why I need a lawyer or something, dude.”

Police kept pressing him, asking for more information and offering promises of help. At one point, they said he could “minimize his involvement” if he kept talking. Snowden was cold, confused, and had no legal help. When he asked again—this time saying directly, “I need a lawyer”—officers finally paused. But it was already too late. They had continued questioning him after clear requests for counsel.

What the Court Said and Why It Matters

The appeals court said Snowden’s statements should have been suppressed. The judges ruled that all three requests were clear and unequivocal. The officers failed to stop the interrogation as required under Miranda v. Arizona.

Even worse, the court said Snowden’s later decision to talk was likely the result of pressure. Police made repeated comments about helping himself, mentioned “mitigating factors,” and left him isolated for hours. This created a coercive environment.

Under Florida law, once a suspect asks for a lawyer, all questioning must stop. Officers are not allowed to ignore the request, continue asking questions, or try to persuade the suspect to talk without legal help.

Why This Decision Affects Defendants in Tampa Bay

If police ignore your request for a lawyer, your statements may be thrown out. The court’s ruling in Snowden sends a clear message: Tampa Bay law enforcement must respect your rights.

At The Brancato Law Firm, P.A., we review every interaction between police and our clients. If you were interrogated after asking for a lawyer, we may be able to suppress key evidence in your case. These details often make the difference between a conviction and an acquittal.

Don’t Let Police Pressure Cost You Your Future

If you were questioned without a lawyer after clearly asking for one, the evidence may be inadmissible. You have the right to remain silent and the right to legal protection.

Call The Brancato Law Firm, P.A. at (813) 727-7159 for a free and confidential consultation. We serve clients across Tampa Bay, including Hillsborough, Pinellas, and Pasco counties. With over 25 years of experience, we defend your rights when it matters most.